True story: Feels Like the First TIme – Chapter 4
I thought for a moment.
“No, let’s try without it,” I said softly.
He took his cock in his hand and rubbed the head up and down the lips of my vagina. He took a deep breath and then placed it at my opening.
Our eyes met.
“Go slow again,” I said, in a voice barely above a whisper.
He rotated his hips forward and the head of his penis penetrated me. I gasped as he moved ahead at a snail’s pace. I could feel his cock opening, and slowly filling me. There was a little bit of discomfort, but no pain, which produced a warm, wonderful feeling.
A few seconds later, his body was resting against mine, and I knew he was completely inside of me. I let out a soft moan when he slowly began to rotate backward and then forward again. God, it felt so much better without a condom. His cock felt almost alive inside of me. It was so warm, and it felt like it was almost pulsing, I couldn’t believe how much better this was, and how good it felt.
He started to pick up the pace and move more rapidly inside of me and thankfully, there was no pain, and even the discomfort was starting to give way, leaving only an amazing sensation from deep inside my body. He was moving faster now, and damn, it was really starting to feel good. I started to get a little tingle in my stomach again, I was getting close!
Just a little bit more Anthony, I’m almost there.
I looked up and observed that his breathing had changed, and he was grunting again. I realized what was happening.
No Anthony, damn it, not yet!
His body went stiff and his cock pulsed and spasmed as he came inside me. Moments later, he collapsed on top of me.
It took a few seconds for his breathing to revert back to normal. As he calmed himself down, his cock shrunk and slipped out of me, and he rolled over to my side.
Our eyes met and he had a big smile on his face, which quickly disappeared, when he saw the exasperated look on mine.
“You mean you didn’t?”
“No,” I said softly.
“Mel… I’m… I’m so sorry.”
“It’s okay Anthony, it was really nice.”
“I wasn’t exactly going for… nice.”
A smile broke across both of our faces.
“Anthony, what you did before that… you know, with your mouth… it was really, really good. And I had one then.”
That brought a little smile to his face.
I could tell he was upset with himself and deep in thought.
“Whatcha thinking about?” I asked softly.
“That was the first time that I’ve ever had sex without a condom, and you’re just so tight… and it… just felt so good…”
He paused for a moment.
“I’m just pissed because I normally have more control than that.”
I gently rubbed his shoulder and our eyes met.
“Anthony… that was one-hundred times better than Monday, so don’t beat yourself up too bad.”
A smile broke across both of our faces.
“So you think you want to do this with me again then?” he asked softly.
“I’ll see you tomorrow.”
His face split into a huge grin.
He leaned in and kissed me. After several seconds, I broke our gentle kiss. I slid out of bed, grabbed my clothes, and went into his bathroom. I cleaned up as best I could before getting dressed and heading home. If I hurried, I’d be able to grab a quick shower before dinner.
It was Friday morning, and my entire family was at the table eating breakfast.
“Why are you in such a good mood runt?”
Because I’m fucking your best friend dummy.
I hadn’t even noticed, but I was whistling a little tune between bites of my toast.
“Todd, I’ve asked you repeatedly not to call her that,” my mom said while scooping out an obscene amount of scrambled eggs onto his plate.
My dad slid the morning paper down several inches and gave Todd an evil ‘stink eye’.
“I’m sorry Mom,” he said sheepishly while looking at my Dad.
“I guess I’m in a good mood because it feels wonderful helping so many kids after school,” I said, with an angelic grin.
My brothers rolled their eyes.
“You’re just the saint of the neighborhood, aren’t you? Scott said sarcastically, with a mouthful of bacon.
I shot him a dirty look.
“Don’t listen to him Kiddo,” my Dad said, “your mother and I are very proud of you for ‘giving back’ like this.”
“I’ve even offered my tutoring services to Todd, and I think if he applies himself, I can get his I.Q. just a little above fifty.”
My two brothers busted up laughing and even my Mom and Dad cracked a little smile.
“I don’t want to be late for school,” I said, before standing up. “Bye Mom.”
“Bye honey,” have a good day,” she said.
I walked over and gave my dad a little peck on the cheek. I then made sure my parents weren’t watching before I looked at my brothers and pretended to scratch a little itch on my nose with my middle finger. All three of their mouths dropped open as I turned around and closed the door behind me.
I was in such a good mood I could barely contain my elation. Even though things weren’t perfect yet with Anthony, they were getting much, much better. We were communicating, and being forthright with each other, and that was making all the difference.
My classes seemed to drag on and even though I was in high spirits, what I really wanted was for the school day to be over so I could get to Anthony’s. Even at lunch, Jenna and Erica’s incessant sex talk and ugly teasing couldn’t ruin my jovial demeanor.
“So why are you in such a good mood?” Danielle asked, during our math class.
“Oh, no reason,” I replied while trying unsuccessfully to wipe the silly little grin off my face.
“If I were to venture a guess, I’d say it was because of a guy.”
A big smile broke across my face.
“Just get your math work done Miss busy-body.”
“I’m happy for you Mel.”
We exchanged knowing smiles and got back to our math problems.
A couple hours later, I was lying in bed naked with Anthony.
“Do you know how long I’ve thought about doing this with you?” he said quietly.
“Knowing how guys are, I bet you were doing more than just thinking about it.”
“Hey, I don’t do that.”
“Of course you don’t.”
He pulled me to him and we kissed. This was so nice. Talking, and being intimate.
I could get used to this.
“Every time your brothers invited me over to swim, I secretly hoped that you’d join us.”
I gave him a little smile.
“Well, you could have asked me to join you.”
“Yeah right, I can just picture it: ‘Hey Todd, can you ask your hot little sister to come out and get in the pool with us?’ That would get me nothing but an instant ass-pummeling.”
He called me beautiful, and now hot.
The way he was talking about me was doing momentous things for my ego.
“You and your friend joined us once in the pool, and you were wearing that little blue swimsuit.”
“Oh my God, you even remember the color of the suit I was wearing?”
He blushed a little as I gently teased him.
“The image of you splashing around in the pool, in that little blue suit, it’s kinda seared into my mind.”
Damn, he’s turning me on.
Suddenly, I remembered I didn’t come over here to just talk and lay in bed naked with him.
“Anthony, I want to…”
I paused, trying to pick the right words.
“You want to what Mel?”
“What you did to me yesterday… ummm… I want to… ummm… try to do that to you.”
His face lit up.
“Yes… but I… I don’t really know what I’m doing…”
“Trust me; anything you want to do down there is probably going to feel really good. Just don’t ummm… use your teeth.”
“So what you’re saying is no biting?”
“Yes… No biting.”
“What about chomping, that’s not good either?”
“Let me see what I can do then.”
He turned from his side onto his back, and I slid the covers down, exposing our naked bodies. His penis was already semi-erect, and once I took it into my hand, it quickly grew to full hardness.
Parent Post: Feels Like the First TIme by melanieatplay
- Feels Like the First TIme - Chapter 2
- Feels Like the First TIme - Chapter 3
- Feels Like the First TIme - Chapter 4
- Feels Like the First TIme - Chapter 5