Birthday Pool Party Ch. 23

Hey guys, sorry this took so long. Real life got in the way. I hope this chapter makes up for it! As always, everyone involved in sexual activity is at least eighteen years old, and this is a world without STI’s. Enjoy.

-Witty

Steven

The rest of spring break passes by in a blur. After taking Marcia’s anal virginity, the quiet girl waddles her way to the other bedroom with Ashley to work things out. Kayla shuts herself in her own bedroom, while Lexi, Hazel and I spend the night in the master bedroom. We have a highly enjoyable threesome, and I end up hosing down both girls’ faces before we all snuggle up in bed to go to sleep.

In the morning, Marcia and Ashley come down to breakfast holding hands and giggling. It looks like they’ve worked things out and are able to touch each other again. I’m glad. They talk and flirt quite a bit at breakfast. At one point, Ashley opens her robe and allows Marcia to suckle at her large breast while the tall blonde giggles.

“So, you guys had a nice night?” Kayla asks.

“Yes!” Ashley breathes as she puts her boobs away.

“We talked, and I feel better now.” Marcia says with a nod.

“Yeah, you ‘talked’, right. Is that what tribbing is called now?” Lexi teases.

“Whatever.” Ashley laughs.

“How did you girls work things out?” I ask.

“By tribbing, we just covered that.” Hazel giggles.

“Yes, we had sex,” Marcia admits with a blush, “but what really helped was the talking.”

“It really did.” Ashley says as she smiles at Marcia before taking a bite of food.

“Good.” Kayla says. “What did you talk about?”

“Well, we talked about how we both love Steven, but we know we can’t be with him.” Ashley answered. “And we talked about how hard it was to bring ourselves to sleep with someone else, and I was just upset that Marcia made it look so easy.”

“Who says you can’t be with him?” Lexi asks.

“You’re with Steven.” Marcia answers with a raised eyebrow.

“Yes, and I always will be, but I can share!” Lexi announces. “With my Slut-sisters, I’ll always share.”

“Don’t I get a say in this?” I ask with a chuckle.

“No.” Lexi responds with a teasing smile.

“Like you’d ever complain about too much pussy.” Kayla rolls her eyes.

“Of course not, and I love all you girls. Very much.” I acknowledge with a nod.

“So, what, we could all be with him?” Ashley asks.

“Why not?” Lexi shrugs.

“They deserve to find their own man.” I state firmly. “A man who can make each girl his number one.”

“And… I still like Shawn.” Marcia admits with a sad expression.

“And I like Josh.” Ashley adds with tears in her eyes. “And I’m still insanely attracted to Tom.”

“Oh.” Lexi says sadly.

“We do each deserve our own man. Steven’s right.” Hazel says.

“I’m glad you understand.” I say. “I love all of you, and I’d love to keep you all to myself, but that isn’t fair to you. You’d always feel like you were in second place compared to Lexi. I’m happy to keep sleeping with you, as long as you aren’t cheating on anyone, but I want you to find your own happiness. Like I did with Lexi.”

“Aw!” Kayla interjects. “How sickeningly sweet!”

“Fuck you, Kayla.” Lexi says with a smile.

Kayla just sticks her tongue out. We continue to chat over breakfast, and basically decide that the girls are free to do as they please, but we all are in love. We agree to just see how things develop and that we’ll always be honest about our feelings. This is hard. I would love to be in a relationship with all four lovely ladies, but they deserve more. Right? I can’t really be with more than one person at a time, can I?

After breakfast, we get ready for the day. Then we all pile into the SUV and drive to the right location for the famous crystal caves of Bermuda. We take a tour of both caves, learning about them and enjoying their beauty.

The six of us grab lunch at a small, local place. Then we head back to the house and change into our bathing suits. I enjoy the next few hours splashing around in the water with the five girls. Tom and his friends are out for the day, so we are able to take advantage of the privacy to really tease each other.

Ashley flashes me before burying my face in her tits so I can enjoy her massive tits. Lexi wades into the shallow water and turns around to moon us. Even Kayla gets in on the teasing, grabbing my bathing suit and yanking it down, showing everyone my cock.

“Kayla!” I exclaim as I pull my swim trunks up.

“You’re welcome!” my daughter teases as she sticks out her tongue before diving into the water.

It may be my imagination, but Kayla has really stepped up her teasing with me. She runs her hands over my bicep, giving me a teasing wink before swimming away. Another time, she jumps on my back and wraps her arms and legs around me as I carry her around. She’s done this before, but this time she presses her heel into my crotch.

When we finish swimming, we all towel off and take showers before dinner. We enjoy a nice meal of chips and grilled burgers, all while chatting and enjoying each others company. Then it’s time to get ready for Tom’s party.

The party goes by in a blur. I see Ashley flirting with Tom, while occasionally glancing back at me with a guilty expression. Ken, Ryan, and John are all chatting up Hazel. The tan girl is laughing and doesn’t seem to feel any guilt at all. Kayla talks with several of Tom’s female friends, and even does a couple shots with them.

For our part, Lexi and I spend the entire evening drinking and talking with Heather. Eventually, we invite her next door. Heather is wild. The beautiful twenty-something eats out Lexi while I hold her hips and fuck her from behind. Heather has me fuck her face, she has me grab her tits and fuck her with the full length of my shaft. Finally, she reaches back, spreads her cheeks, and begs me to fuck her ass.

When I can take it no longer, I pull out and cum on Lexi’s lightly-freckled face. Then we shower. Heather has me fuck her against the shower glass before shoving myself down her throat and feeding her another load of cum.

We return to the bed, where I watch Lexi and Heather tribbing while waiting to recharge. Then I finally get my dick into Lexi. The redheaded nymphomaniac lays on her back with her legs over my shoulders as I fuck her. Heather than sits on Lexi’s face and rides my girlfriend to an intense orgasm.

Only when both girls are laying on their backs, naked breasts heaving as they gasp for breath while completely covered in cum, do we stop. The girls clean themselves up and then return to my bed, fully nude. That’s how we fall asleep.

I am woken up at 3:00AM by Heather sucking on my dick. She then gives me a titty-fuck until I’m ready to pop. The buxom beauty takes me back in her mouth so I can squirt between her lips. Heather shows me my cum before swallowing and climbing back up into my arms to fall asleep.

The next morning we fuck again, me on top of Heather, taking her in missionary as Lexi watches and runs her hand over my ass. Heather looks so beautiful as her face scrunches up while she cums. Only once I fill her with my seed do we head down to breakfast.

Heather exchanges contact information with us before heading out on her own for the day. Maybe someday our paths will cross again. Either way, we will always have the memories we’ve made. We will all have the memories we’ve made in Bermuda.

“Sounds like you had a fun night in there.” Ashley teases when she catches me alone after breakfast.

“You could hear?” I ask.

“Yeah, I found out Heather is a screamer when I came home last night.” Ashley responds with a wink as she raises her hand for a high-five. “Nice work!”

“Thanks, I guess.” I reply as I slap her hand.

“You’re welcome!” Ashley giggles, before her face suddenly turns serious. “I wanted to tell you something.”

“What’s that?” I ask.

“I didn’t sleep with Tom.” she states simply.

“I see.” I reply. “Why not?”

“I-I’m not sure.” Ashley answers slowly. “I guess it’s not just because of you.”

“Then why?” I repeat.

“I’m a Slut-sister, but that doesn’t mean I have to sleep with everyone I’m attracted to.” Ashley explains with a shrug. “I slept with you because I was insanely attracted to you, then it turned into more. I like the sex better when it means more. I’m gonna be more selective about who I spread my legs for.”

“That’s probably a good thing.” I reply with a smile.

“I think so, too.” she nods.

We talk for a few more minutes before the other girls find us. Then we get down to packing for our journey home. The girls tease Hazel about fucking three guys again, which is when Hazel admits that Ken, John, and Ryan all made her airtight last night. I actually do feel a slight twinge of jealousy as I imagine three guys using Hazel at once, but I know the sweet girl deserves to be happy. If this is what makes her happy, so be it.

We pack away our clothes and our souvenirs, happy with the time we’ve spent in Bermuda. Then Lexi and I return the rental SUV before taking a bus back to the house. We then spend the rest of our time relaxing and eating the remainder of the food in the house. It’s time to leave.

Two cars arrive to take us and our luggage to the airport. The girls are chatting constantly about the great time they’ve had here. Kayla is texting Ian, Ashley is posting to social media, all while Lexi and Hazel tease each other.

Passing through airport security is without incident, and soon we’re waiting for the plane at the terminal. Then our first flight is called. Lexi makes a joke during the flight about joining the mile high club, but I remind her that this is real life, not a porno.

After two flights and an eight hour layover, we arrive back at LAX at approximately 9:00AM Sunday morning. Yeah, we got to sleep on the layover, and on the plane, but still, we are all completely exhausted as we get into the vans that are driving us back to the house.

“Hey Steven?” Lexi inquires on the drive.

“Yes?” I respond.

“I was texting Nicole, and she wants to know if she can stop by today?” Lexi asks.

“Really? You’re not too tired?” I ask.

“We’re still young, old man.” Hazel calls out from the back.