I could feel the heat emanating from her body. I could hear the wet sounds as my head brushed her pussy lips. However, she stopped me just before I could enter her.
“Is something wrong?”
“No, I… I just know that once we do this…” The words hung in the air for almost a minute, after she slowly trailed off.
“Once we do this, things will really be over.”
It was only after I said that, that the sadness I had expected to see finally poured out of her.
“Maybe that’s a good thing,” I told her.
“I think so, too. Let’s hope I’m right.”
Slowly, she lowered herself down onto me, letting my enlarged tip push its way through her tight entrance, but she was unable to get more than the first few inches inside.
“It’s been so long since I’ve done this. Ben and I have barely had sex in the last few months.”
“It’s ok,” I told her. “I’ve got lube in the bedroom, and condoms if we need them.”
“My parents put me on the pill the moment they learned I had a boyfriend, and we don’t need lube. I just need to adjust.”
She started slowly moving up and down, with just three inches of my girth entering her at a time. She leaned over me to grab the top of the couch for support, allowing me to once again suck on her pink nipples.
“Oh, you’re killing me, Alex.”
After a few minutes, when her cunt juices had completely soaked my cock, I asked her, “How do you feel?”
“Amazing.”
“Do you want to feel even better?”
I didn’t wait for a response. I simply lifted my hips and started fucking her with the full length of my cock.
“Oh, shit!”
Her body trembled as I slammed into her over and over again, repeatedly forcing her walls to make room for me.
“Am I hurting you?”
“In a good way.”
Over and over I stretched her little hole, which was far tighter than Emma or Amanda’s, until her back arched and her whole body shook with an earth-shattering orgasm that caused her to collapse on top of me with no breath in her lungs.
“Fuck, that was good.”
“Yeah?”
“Of course. I came fast. I haven’t had sex that good a long time.”
“Well, I stay in practice.”
“You mean with Emma and Amanda?”
My face went pale. I had made that comment without thinking, and had no idea that Annie knew about both girls. As far as I knew, she still thought I was dating Emma.
“How did you find out?”
“They haven’t exactly been quiet about the fact that you’re banging both of them. They talk about you in the locker room, and they fight about you all the time. The whole cheer squad knows, and half of the football team thinks you’re a god.”
“Really?”
“Yeah. I mean, you were cool when they thought you were just dating Emma. Now, you’re the guy who you conquered two cheerleaders. Three now, I guess.”
I looked down at the floor, feeling a little sick to my stomach. I had never thought of Emma as a conquest. She was one of my best friends, and I really did lie Annie too, so hearing her say that I had “conquered” them made me feel like a sleazebag.
I picked up my phone when it started buzzing.
“Is Amanda checking in on us again?”
“She wants to know if you’re ok.”
“Tell her I’m very ok,” she said, smiling at me.
We didn’t bother putting our clothes back on. We didn’t even bother cleaning up. Annie and I simply turned on the next movie we found, knowing the night was far from over.
“I don’t suppose you’d want to go again?” she asked me, and moments later I was once again deeply penetrating her with my well-lubricated dick.
It became a pattern throughout the night. We would watch something for a few minutes, and then either go to the bedroom or just fuck on the couch the moment I was hard again. It only ended when both of us collapsed in my bed and fell fast asleep, completely exhausted.
————————-
Leave a Reply