“It would be amazing, but let’s not go there yet” Hailey said. She was clearly the most skeptical that we could convince Danielle. After all, it was her sister, and she knew her well.
“I can’t wait any longer” Melanie said, grabbing my hand. “I love the both of you. I want you in my life, always. If she says no…”
Melanie was about to cry. She had also just said she loved us. It wasn’t really something any of us had thrown out there directly yet. Hailey and I came to her comfort, and the three of us group hugged.
“I love you both too” Hailey said. She was trembling slightly in the embrace. She was scared of it not coming together. These relationships had been cultivating for years now, and the prospects of it all being done wasn’t something they wanted to face. I didn’t either.
“I…” I finally said after a pause. “I love you girls. You mean the world to me.”
My shirt had been soaked through from the tears of both girls as they cried on either of my shoulders. This really did feel like the all or nothing moment. Years of sexual passion, but also getting to know each other, had brought us here. And, one bad response from Danielle would set the whole situation on fire. Hailey was right – I didn’t know if I had it in me to destroy Danielle if she put an “it’s me or nothing” ultimatum out there.
…
The three of us decided it was best to all go together. Danielle was going to need some reassuring, and that could only really come from every party being present. I told Danielle that we needed to discuss something important, and we arranged the next night for it to take place.
The four of us sat around Danielle and Hailey’s family’s living room. There was a lot of awkward silence, and the exchanging of little pleasantries, as Danielle awaited what she figured to be a life changing conversation.
“So, what’s on your mind?” Danielle finally asked. I looked down and noticed her hands were shaking slightly. Everybody in the room seemed to exchange deep breaths. Then, I had to get into it.
“Danielle, you’re the most important person in my life” I started. Hailey and Melanie nodded – we had already agreed this was the right way to start. “I’m sorry that I’ve put you through these awkward situations over the years. You’ve really been incredible in sticking by me, and accepting the oddities. I…I have one more to ask of you.”
Danielle studied me. It was almost like she was trying to guess the words before they came out, and then measured whatever she heard. This was one of the few times she was holding a lot of the power. It was her desire to stick with me that led her to accepting my behaviors. But, she held the cards to throw a major wrench in the future here.
“I’m ready to get out of here” I continued. “I’m ready to move on, get my own place, and find my future. The only problem is I’m not ready to lose any of you. I want you all to come move with me, and live with me. We can all start a fun life in our new city.”
I couldn’t get a read on Danielle’s face. Sometimes, it looked like she was about to get angry. Others, it looked like she was contemplating my words. Finally, she started.
“Where, Utah?” she asked. It looked like she might start yelling, but then she calmed down. “All this time, I thought this was eventually going to stop. I thought it would just be us.”
“I know” I said sympathetically. I knew this was my one shot at an explanation to win her over. “When we were all younger, I thought this all might be a phase, too. But, I really do genuinely care about all of you. Each of you brings happiness to my life. It’s not like we’d never get time to ourselves. But, I have feelings for all of you, and I don’t want to hide that.”
I didn’t really like the look on Danielle’s face. It seemed like she was holding in emotions. It felt like she was leaning towards no.
“Think about it sis” Hailey suddenly chimed in. “We really do get along so well most of the time. We could spend so much more time together. Plus – you hate cooking, right? Leave it to me. Fantastic meals every night. Healthy ones!”
“Plus, I know he bores you with those college football games” Melanie spoke up too now. “That’s my wheelhouse. No use being forced to do something you hate.”
Danielle seemed a bit more intrigued by Hailey’s offerings to cook than Melanie’s offerings to take me to herself to watch something I liked. Danielle had accepted her sister much more than Melanie over the years, and that connection was my biggest fear.
“Also I have money” Melanie blurted out from nowhere.
Everybody paused and looked at each other, and then towards her. We had all talked about getting jobs in the new place, but none of us were working now. We had all recently finished school. Everybody was getting their life in order. The thoughts of major loans was scary, when none of us had guaranteed work.
“I used to work summers with my dad” she explained. “He paid me well, and I never spent any of it. It could give us a buffer until we got consistent work.”
“That’s so nice of you” Hailey said, hugging her friend. I looked over at Melanie with a gracious smile. Danielle watched, and seemed to get a sense of how much we all really did mean to each other. That this wasn’t all about keeping two sex dolls around the house with her, but to actually have a life with people who meant everything to me.
Danielle got up, went into the kitchen, and got some water. The three of us looked around with darting eyes as we waited for her to say something.
“Can I think about it?” she said after a lengthy silence. “All these years, I always had it pictured that it would just be the two of us. This is hard to wrap my head around. I’m not saying no, but I’d really like to make sure I give it fair thought.”
“Of course” I said, getting up and going over to Danielle to give her a kiss. “I know this isn’t exactly what you had in mind. But I think it would be an amazing time for all of us. I don’t picture my future without you in it.”
“Think about it sis” Hailey said, embracing her sister next. “We’d have a lot of fun away from the parents.”
“I’d enjoy becoming closer to you” Melanie offered last. The tension between her and Danielle had softened since the money gesture. Danielle said goodnight to us all and went into her room.
…
That night, Hailey, Melanie and I stayed in Melanie’s bed. There were no sexual advances. I laid on my back, and held each of them in an arm. We were nervous, and we didn’t sleep much. We talked, nodded off for a little bit, and talked again.
The next morning, we awoke with a jolt from the vibration of a phone. There was a text message from Danielle.
“I’m open to this arrangement. But, I’m curious what the details will be. Why don’t you guys decide on a location and find a place? If Melanie is fronting most of the money, it should mostly be up to her, with regards to the house. If you find something tempting, let me know, and we can discuss it.”
There were shrieks of excitement from the girls as they finished reading the message.
“Let’s get dressed and go!” Melanie squealed. “Let’s find something today!”
“Where are we even going?” Hailey asked with a giggle. It was all smiles now.
“We will figure that out” I said, before embracing the two of them. “The only thing that matters is we get to stay together. I’m so excited.”
We all embraced for a while, before finally breaking it.
“This is the first time it feels like we’re all approved for everything we do” Melanie said. “Technically, we’re together too now” she teased Hailey. Before I knew what was happening, Hailey and Melanie were kissing. The two held each other, and kissed deeply as their chests rubbed together. It was Hailey who dropped her hand into Melanie’s bottoms first, rubbing at her clit and forcing some moans from her mouth. The passion boiled over quickly, and soon they were naked.
“Ah ah” Hailey said teasingly and held up her hand as I started to approach. “You’ll have to get used to this. You can’t always just break up our lesbian habits right away” she continued with a sly grin. Then, the two turned back towards each other, moved their lower halves into position, and started to trib in front of me. They held onto each other as they grinded their pussies together, clit finding clit, and moans starting to pick up. My erection was ready to break out of my shorts, but I decided to let them continue to go at it.
“Whoever doesn’t cum gets to fuck” I tossed out, and that changed the girls approach. They focused on trying to shift more pressure on the other’s clit, while minimizing it on their own. They wrestled for power, and whoever got on top grinded down sensually into the other.
“Just cum already so I can fuck that cock” Melanie said, with the upper hand at the moment. Hailey was beneath her, writhing a bit, but doing everything to keep her composure. She reached up and teased Melanie’s breasts, and that was enough to distract her and change the balance. Hailey rolled on top of Melanie and rubbed her pussy back and forth on Melanie’s clit.
“Cum bitch” she said teasingly, and then kissed Melanie again. Then she put her hand on her neck playfully, but enough to prove her point, and held her against the mattress. “It doesn’t matter if you’re getting dominated by him or me, it always makes you cum doesn’t it? You can’t hold it, so just let it go. Cum so I can get that cock.”
“No” Melanie shrieked and squealed from beneath her. Her nipples were rock hard and her neck was getting red. “No no no no FUCK” she cried out as she came violently, her hips bucked and her legs shook against Hailey. Hailey got off and gave her clit a quick kiss, looking down triumphantly.
“Now your prize” I said, jumping onto the bed and tackling Hailey onto her stomach. Instantly, I stuffed my cock into her pussy from behind and started to pump her deep.
“Oh fucking fuck” Hailey moaned and half screamed. I gripped Hailey’s hair and pulled it back as I started to pound her from behind, creaming her g-spot again and again.
“Only one person truly dominates here” I grinned as I tugged Hailey’s hair more. Her back arched and I slapped her ass.
Leave a Reply