Literotic asexstories – Neighbor Girls Ch. 03 by VanillaUnicorn,VanillaUnicorn
This story is the final part of a three part series and it is advised to read the story from the beginning as each part continues directly from the last.
*******
The Neighbor Girls
By: VanillaUnicorn
The next few months were a whirlwind. Kathy’s divorce had gotten finalized. Seems she was owed a favor and it got fast tracked. It didn’t hurt that John hadn’t fought it at all either. John had gained the house in the divorce in exchange for the savings they had accumulated at the bank.
Paul put his house on the market there and they went about looking for a home out in Utah. By a bit a strange luck they happened onto a decent sized ranch that was turn-key and also happened to be in their price range. They didn’t hesitate to put in an offer and the previous owner must have been in a hurry to sell because their offer went through right away.
Not only had Lindsay become pregnant but so had Kathy not long after they got to Utah. It was a shock to the older woman because she thought she was too old for it to happen. Not long after settling in to their new home, they were all informally married to Paul. It was decided that Lindsay would be the legal primary wife of the group since it had been her actions that had started everything in the first place and of the three women she was the one most in love with Paul. It was a good thing that the house was huge because it seemed like he had a knack for knocking his wives up.
Things were great there and everyone was happy. Paul and Kathy had talked further into his dealings with Rachel and she finally convinced him to come clean to her daughters about the mystery woman.
Both young women were furious at him when he explained everything that had happened between them but he spared them the details of the actual sex that had gone on. It was Kathy who played peacemaker as she explained that Lindsay was partially to blame as she had cut him off with very little communications and it could be assumed that he thought the relationship was over. They each forgave him though and Kathy was happy that she could help.
Out of the blue Lindsay had thought about something. She sat down with Paul one day and told him, “There is something I need to tell you.” He told her to go ahead.
Lindsay says, “Well I don’t know why I didn’t think to tell you this before, maybe it was when you explained things with this Rachel woman that it had occurred to me but back when we first got pregnant…”
She stopped looking him in the eye. Paul says, “Go ahead it’s alright.”
“Well back then, Leah and I weren’t the only ones pregnant.” Lindsay says.
“What are you saying?” Paul asks.
“Well Carrie and Nicki were possibly pregnant too. I don’t know specifics but it was highly likely. Remember how Nicki went to go on vacation with her parents?” Lindsay asks.
“Yeah that was right after the last time I saw her.” Paul replies.
“Well when mom found out about us she told our aunt about it but she had already made Nicki get checked out too and it turned out she was pregnant. At the time I guess Nicki refused to say what had happened but when Leah and I came up pregnant too a few months later, I guess my aunt went ballistic. We lied and told her that she slept with Carrie’s older brother Jacob and from then on that’s why we stopped talking to Carrie because my aunt called their house and freaked out on Carrie’s parents,” Lindsay continues.
“How did you know Carrie was pregnant if you didn’t talk to her anymore?” Paul asks.
“Well when the whole thing went down with Nicki and Jacob, they were already dealing with the fact that Carrie had come up pregnant, they even pressed charges against that guy she was dating.” Lindsay says.
“How could they press charges, all you girls were over 18 and Carrie was 19 like you?” Paul asks.
“Well I don’t know exactly the truth behind it but both Leah and I think that her parents told her to lie to the police and say that the boy raped her. I guess they did a check on Carrie and she showed signs of forceful entry, most likely from that day with you, so it more or less backed up the claim. They did the whole trial thing and with that as evidence I guess they convicted the guy.” She says.
“Well that doesn’t make me feel any better, why are you telling me this now?” Paul asks.
“Well I was just thinking since you are the father to their kids if they had them, would it be so bad if they were interested to maybe have them here, you know as a wife and as family together?” She asks.
Paul thinks about it, hell he was already married to a mother and her two daughters what’s the difference if they added more. He thought back to that day at his house, they were all attractive women and the sex had been really good, not to mention they could be the mothers of his children already. He turned to Lindsay and says, “We will talk about this as a family, if everyone is on board then it’s a yes from me.”
Not surprising it had been a resounding yes from all three women, so Paul had agreed like he said he would. Given that Nicki was related to them she was easier to get ahold of. After a lengthy conversation with Lindsay over the phone, Nicki had agreed to at least come out and give it a try. She didn’t say much about what had happened in the time since but would tell them more when she got there.
Carrie was proving more difficult to track down. Her family had apparently moved in an attempt to avoid the drama of Carrie’s rape trial and pregnancy. They would have to keep trying to track her down.
The pursuit of more information about their formal close friend was proving so tricky that it seemed like the whole idea was doomed from the start. It was almost like once she left their home state, it was like she had vanished off the face of the earth. They still continued on with what little they had though. The search got delayed some when Lindsay gave birth to her second child with her now husband. They wanted to keep the sex of the baby a surprise and they were pleasantly happy when Lindsay delivered a healthy baby boy, Paul’s second son.
A few weeks passed since Lindsay gave birth and there was still no luck with finding Carrie but they did have some clues as to where she might be, mostly things were pointing them towards California. Lindsay and Leah both decided to check it out, driving out to California together even though Leah had recently become pregnant with her second child as well.
With both of her daughters gone for the foreseeable future, Kathy caught up with Paul just as he was feeding the horses and wanted to talk.
“So I didn’t want to bring this up with Lindsay and Leah around since it is still a sore subject with them but I would strongly advise you call Rachel.” She said to him.
“Why do you want me to call Rachel?” He asked.
“Well it would be very important for you to hear what she has to say.” Kathy told him with a serious look in her eyes. No sooner had she told him that, that she walked off leaving him to guess what the whole thing was about.
Pulling out his phone, he found Rachel’s saved number and hit call. He had talked to her a few times after moving back to the big city but once Lindsay moved in she was the last thing on his mind. The phone rang and rang before going to voicemail. He left her a message letting her know that he called and that he would try again. No sooner had he hung up that he phone rang. It was Rachel already calling him back.
“Hey sorry I wasn’t quick enough to get to the phone before the stupid voicemail got it. Kathy told me you would be calling.” She apologized profusely.
“Yeah she just told me to call you. What’s up? Is everything alright?” He asked.
“Things are good. I got that divorce from Jack. He wasn’t happy about it but the way the situation was panning out it was for the better.” She told him happily but there seemed to be something she wasn’t telling him.
“Oh that’s great. I’m happy to hear that it finally happened. I know you will be so much happier now.” He replied back to her.
“Oh I definitely am. Especially now after hearing from you.” She says.
“But that isn’t why I wanted you to call me. I needed to tell you that you are a father.” She tells him.
He smiles and then replies, “Yeah both Lindsay and Leah actually and Kathy is pregnant now. It’s great.”
“No you aren’t hearing me, you are a father.”
“No I hear you, my kids are amazing you would love them.” He replied while what she said went over his head.
“No listen to me Paul. You are a father… As in WE are parents. Do you get what I’m saying?” She says to him.
What she said played over and over in his head until he finally picked up on the emphasized ‘we’ that Rachel had said to him. That seemed to break his brain temporarily.
“Hello? Are you still there? Talk to me.” A panicked Rachel said on the other end of the line.
“But how?” Was all Paul was able to get out.
“Honey we both know how babies are made. Do you have any idea how many times you came inside me that day. I guess I should have mentioned back then that I wasn’t on any form of birth control but I figured at my age the chances of it happening were slim and none with none the most likely answer. Well I was wrong and now we have a wonderful daughter. I couldn’t think of what to name her so I decided to go with your mom’s name and I called her Lilly.” Rachel explained.
Paul was absolutely dumbfounded by the revelation. The more he thought about it the more he should have seen it coming just like with Lindsay and her sister. He wasn’t upset by it, if anything he was actually happy about it since it made the likelihood that his young wives would be more welcome to the idea of her joining them.
“I love you. I’m sorry I didn’t say it before but I do, I love you. That day with you when we made our daughter was one of the happiest of my life and I don’t mean just because the sex was amazing. Well it was but there was more to it that day and I think I knew then that something like that might happen and I think that was why I invited you over in the first place. I haven’t watched our tapes from that day yet but after we get off this call I think I will. I know Kathy would love to watch.” He told her.
Leave a Reply