I was going to have a really hard time waiting until Prom night.
***
For the rest of the week, Ellie kept up the sexual pressure. My mind was torn between two resolutions: One, that she would eventually tire of messing with my head and things would just go back to normal; Two, that she wouldn’t stop and inevitably, Ellie would seduce me.
My brain told me to hope for the first result. At least, when I was alone or with Monica I hoped for the first result. Only at these times could I think rationally and comprehend the concept of fidelity.
But every time I saw the cute girl and her tight ass, my hormones took over the decision-making and I could feel my mouth watering and my muscles tensing with desire to give in to my animal instincts and mate with her. Getting laid seemed to dominate my thinking.
WHO I had sex with was rapidly becoming less important. And so I was secretly hoping Ellie would find a way to seduce me. Just give me the right excuse and I’d give into temptation.
Monica, so sexy and so loving, may or may not have realized just how fragile teenage fidelity really is. But she really was doing everything she could to keep her man satisfied and not take that chance. We were a happy couple and we used every trick in the book to sneak around our parents and find private places to get each other off.
My teenaged body was always ready and willing. And yet, there was something not quite… satisfying… about cumming so much without ever bursting inside the warm, wet receptacles where our dicks are meant, biologically, to ejaculate.
At least Danielle and Cherys were gone. I don’t know how much more frazzled my mind would have been if they’d kept up their nightly sexual unions. But still, I found myself quite distracted, in more ways than one, when Game Night came around again.
This Friday seemed so much… less… than the last Friday. We were visiting another high school perhaps an hour’s drive away, so I didn’t feel the home crowd energy. This wasn’t a rival school and it was a game we were expected to win handily. Everything about this night felt like an emotional let down.
Even Monica’s blowjob.
With the longer drive, most of the players, staff, and cheerleaders would be taking the team bus. But a few Seniors always elected to find their own transportation. As such, Nate and Ellie carpooled with me and Monica in my ancient, but roomy, American sedan.
Quite often, while driving to the game, Monica would give me a blowjob to take the nervous edge away before we split up to head into the locker rooms. I always played my best games when I was relaxed like this. But with two friends in the backseat, we couldn’t do it this time.
Still, after we arrived, Monica pulled me into a dark corner of the empty school to try and work one out of me. For whatever reason, the fear of getting caught or the time crunch to get dressed and out on the field, I couldn’t get off. She speed- blew me for three minutes before we both just gave up. And so I found myself with a lot of pent-up nervous energy.
I played like shit.
I dropped three passes and didn’t score once. Fortunately, the rest of the offense picked up the slack and with a pounding running game, we won easily and in record fast time. Once the game was secure during the fourth quarter, Coach benched his starters and put in the reserves. So I spent the last ten minutes with nothing to do but watch the cheerleaders.
Monica and Ellie were on fire that night. I still had my pent-up arousal. So while watching their brief panty flashes and tight ass shots, not to mention the bouncing boobs, I found myself with my school jacket in my lap to cover up my hardon.
Even the opposing fans decided it would be more fun to watch our cheerleaders than witness their football team getting crushed. I could see the fire in Monica’s eyes as she basked in the attention, and I was already trying to figure out a way to get some action from her before we had to head home.
It seemed that Monica and Ellie were of like mind when the game ended. Before we split up to head into the locker rooms, Monica plastered a wet kiss on me and warned me, “Take a FAST shower. I’ll meet you at your car.”
To our surprise, Ellie jumped into Nate’s arms and said the same thing. Her skin was flushed bright red from combined exertion and arousal. And she even paused to wink at me before chewing on Nate’s ear.
I don’t think Nate or I had ever gotten dressed that fast before. Very quickly, we were the first players out the doors and headed to my car.
The girls were waiting, having not even bothered to clean themselves up. So they were sweaty and gorgeous and horny as hell when we arrived. From the short game and the fast showers, we had an extra hour of time before our parents expected us home.
Nate knew a quiet place to park that was only ten minutes away. And after he gave me directions, Ellie practically assaulted him in my backseat. Like I said, they’d dated briefly last year in the way any co-ed circle of friends eventually tries dating each other. And I knew for a fact that they’d screwed at least on a couple of occasions. No love, no commitments, just lustful attention. So this was nothing new for them.
Monica was all over me as we pulled out of the parking lot. Once we got on the road she had my fly open and actually had my dick in her mouth. Man, if I’d known she would do this with our friends in the backseat, I would have had her give me the pre-game blowjob in the car. Still, a post-game BJ was better than no BJ. And between her lips and the erotic noises coming from the backseat, my mind was whirling and I had to remind myself to focus on the road lest this become a very short, disastrous trip.
By the time we arrived at the local lover’s lane, I was on the verge of cumming. I managed to maneuver us to a parked location a good twenty feet from the nearest other High Schooler’s car. Then a split-second after I turned off the engine, my hands were on Monica’s head, my fingers tangled in her hair as I prepared to fire away.
But just before I could shoot off, Ellie’s bubble-gum voice cracked the silence. “Hey, Mon, let’s switch!”
The momentary thought of Ellie’s head in my lap nearly set me off. But Monica’s potential reaction caused absolute panic to flood my brain, and my whole body went stiff as I jerked in surprise.
“Hmm?” Monica popped her head off me and turned to look into the backseat.
Ellie had quite the self-satisfied expression on her face as she reclined back against Nate’s chest. One of his hands was underneath her skirt and the other cupped a breast from underneath her sweater, and from the flushed look and sweat on her forehead, she seemed to just be coming down from quite the orgasm.
“Come on, aren’t you just a little curious?” I saw Ellie’s arm wiggle and then Monica’s gaze dropped down towards Nate’s crotch. I saw her eyes go wide as she must have been seeing Ellie’s hand wrapped around his hard erection.
My view was blocked by the seat, and I wasn’t particularly interested in seeing it for myself. Instead, I was locked in on Ellie’s half-naked body. Sure, I’d seen her in a bikini before, which covered far less skin. But if Nate moved his hands just a few inches in select directions, I would be seeing Ellie’s pussy or her nipples for the first time.
I glanced to Nate’s face. He was similarly staring straight at Monica, no doubt imagining all the things he could be doing with her. And believe it or not, I wasn’t feeling jealous. I knew of his submerged crush on her and I couldn’t begrudge him for the feeling the way he did. No way would he turn down any opportunity with my gorgeous girlfriend.
But his opinion wasn’t the one that mattered. Nor mine, really. It was as if all four of us knew the only possible objection would be coming from Monica. And after a long, pregnant silence, Monica finally exhaled. “N- no, we shouldn’t.” Her statement did not carry the note of finality I had expected.
“Come on…” Ellie’s voice was a purr. “No sex. No commitments. Just once, play around a little or you’ll be wondering for the rest of your life what it might have been like. More to the point, your boyfriend will be wondering for the rest of HIS life. But here you can supervise him and we’ve got a time limit. It’s the best chance you’ll ever have.”
I could see Monica take a deep gulp. Her right hand was still on my hard cock, and she was absently stroking it while staring down at Nate’s. Neither of us had ever touched another person sexually before. Were we really ready to be monogamous forever, never knowing what could have been?
“No sex. And just this once,” Monica stated flatly to nobody in particular, and then she had let go of me and was popping the passenger door. Ellie quickly opened her door and the two girls switched places in a matter of seconds.
Nate almost went catatonic as Monica slid across my backseat and tentatively wrapped her hand around his bare, bulging dick. I saw this in the corner of my eye before Ellie climbed in next to me and was soon leaning across the seat, her face only inches from mine.
“Hey there, hunk…” she cooed.
I was frozen in trepidation of what was about to happen. When she first moved to kiss me my head automatically backed away. It was a conditioned response to her flirting with me for the past year and my struggle to be loyal.
I glanced into the backseat, and saw Monica and Nate tentatively coming together for their first kiss. Nate clearly wanted it, but like me, Monica seemed really, really nervous.
Ellie caught my reaction and turned my gaze back to her. She fixed me with a lopsided grin. “Come on, just imagine I’m Cherys.”
My jaw dropped as my dream girl’s image dropped over Ellie’s similar features. And then she’d taken advantage of my unmoving state and gaping mouth to press her own open mouth against mine.
I swear a lightning bolt came down out of the heavens and zapped us. Maybe it was punishment for our immoral activity, but it sent a crackle of electricity up and down my spine.
Now I’m not going to say anything bad about the chemistry between me and Monica. We’d always had passion. But there was something about this first kiss with Ellie that sent a thrill into me like nothing else. I knew immediately that it had changed me forever.
Leave a Reply