Dad kind of chuckled and looked at me seriously, “you do have condoms right son? I am fairly sure you are going to get lucky tonight. She seems very taken with you”. I rolled my eyes to the back of my head and pulled my wallet out…” yep, I am in the Army dad…mandatory when you go on leave…” little bro is behind me laughing. We made our way back out to the table and the torture continued…I was to sit between Amanda and Sis, mom was next to sis, and bro and dad were on the other side of Amanda.
Thankfully, we made it through dinner without too much hassle and were sitting there talking again and I notice a hand on my left leg…it is sis. She just put her hand on my leg and let it sit there. Then on cue, Amanda puts her hand on my right leg and lets it rest there. My god, these women are going to kill me, I am sure of it. I keep my composure and we all finally get up and head out of the restaurant. Amanda announces that she will take me and sis back to the apartment, she had to go over some class schedules with her to make sure they were going to be in the same classes. Everyone gets hugs all around and we all head out to our separate cars.
Sis was here this time, so I was relegated to the back seat…probably better for my sanity anyway. We all get in and Amanda starts the car. Sis looks back at me and says “are you ok? Amanda did not hurt you too bad, did she?” They both start to laugh at my ghost white appearance at this point. Amanda got out of the spot and starts driving back to sis’s apartment.
Sis turns around in her seat a little so she can look at me and says, “sorry bro, I did not want you to come on too strong or be too obvious, so Amanda and I set this up just in case mom and dad pulled the ‘old show up and surprise everyone trick on us’.” She really was incredibly good at this whole psychology and sociology stuff. I looked up at her and could not be mad at those blue eyes looking at me. I said, “I kind of figured it out when Amanda asked me if we had played around yet…” Sis smacked Amanda on the shoulder and said, “No wonder he looked like you had just told him you wanted to have his babies or something when you guys got there…”
Amanda apologized to both of us and I could tell it was sincere, and then she looked at sis and said, “So…have you guys had sex yet or not?” Sis looked at me, I think she was reading my thoughts…I did not care if she told her best friend in the world, if she trusted her enough to have her help us tonight then I trusted her too. She answered Amanda “yes, we have Amanda and it has been even better than we used to dream about at night in the dorms”. Amanda’s jaw drops “you mean?” Sis just shook her head up and down.
At this point I am clueless to the inner circle language of these two so I just kind of watch the lights going by outside the window and thank god I made it through tonight well I thought I had…
We got back to the apartment and Amanda did come up and her and sis were going over class schedules for the upcoming term and talking about school stuff. I was just sitting on the couch mindlessly watching something on the TV as the girls talked and giggled and carried on. I must have dozed off at some point.
I woke up with a little start as I felt a hand on my shoulder, it was sis, she was sitting next to me on the couch and I could see Amanda sitting behind her in the chair to the side. Amanda had an almost sheepish look on her face and was biting her lower lip. Sis started talking to me, “Do you forgive us for putting you through that earlier?”
I was not mad; I was just happy that somehow, I pulled off the whole thing without screwing up everything sis had put so much effort into. I looked her and then Amanda and said, “of course I do, it would have been nice to have a little heads up, but I understand too. Hell, it is not every day I am sandwiched between two drop dead gorgeous women”.
Sis giggled a little and said, “You think Amanda is cute too do you…?”
This one I saw coming but was not sure if I was right or not…so I just played along and said, “yes, I do. She is unbelievably beautiful, and obviously a particularly good friend since you trust her as much as you do. I know I would not have told anyone about us, guys have to tell any hot secrets they have to their friends and that normally screws everything up in the long run. Girls are little smarter about it when it comes to certain things. Those are very sexy qualities”.
Sis had a look of I told you so, on her face when she turned to look at Amanda sitting there. She motioned her to do something. Soon Amanda was standing and came over next to me and sat down and looked me in the eyes. “I am sorry that I was so blunt earlier, but your sis and I have talked about you every day for the past three years. If her dream was coming true, or about to I wanted to help her anyway I could”.
She continued, “I know guys might not think like this, but we really are the best friends in the world and have been through quite a bit in the past three years together. I wanted her to have everything she was dreaming of”. She laughed a little, and said, “hell if you absolutely would not touch her because she was your stepsister, I even offered to seduce you…” She was biting her lower lip again…There it was, I figured there was more to this than just her apologizing.
Sis could tell she was getting nervous and stepped in and said, “Amanda has been with some real losers in the recent past, and she wanted to make sure at least one of us was able to be with a nice guy that would actually love us and not be a mean asshole.” “after listening to me talk about you for so long, you are kind of her ideal guy at this point too…”
Now the young and dumb part of me comes in and I say without thinking, “you want me to choose her or you?” As I said it, I knew it was stupid and dumb…but I was only 18 give me a little break…
Amanda is now mortified and shying away, and sis looks me in the eye and says, “no you fool, we are asking you if you would share what we have with her a little. Together…” Now I am dumbfounded…sis is asking me to have a three-way with her best friend? I sit there for a moment and it dawns on me… stupid this is her best friend and she is lonely and has been taken advantage of by guys she should not have been seeing in the first place. I wise up and pull Amanda over towards me and put my arm around her shoulders.
Sis is watching me closely, I say, “Amanda I am sorry, you have to remember I am still a young guy that is really new to everything with grown women…I am used to dealing with girls and all their stupid drama. Sis is opening my eyes to what the real world and real women really want, and I think I understand what you two are asking”. “Sis is obviously living out a dream she has had for years and she would like you to experience some of what she is right now”.
Sis looked over at me with approving eyes and a small smile.
Amanda looks at me and says with tears coming out of her eyes, “yes…”
I look at sis and feel like a complete dirt bag for making Amanda cry…and she can see it in my eyes…I say “well I am guessing you two have already talked about this at some point…what do I need to know so I do not do something that makes one of you upset or uncomfortable?” Sis comes over and sits next me on the other side and whispers in my ear, “you and Amanda go in the bedroom together. I will give you two about an hour or so together. Please treat her like you did me on that first night…please… then I will come in after that”. “Once we are all together, as long as everyone else agrees we will do whatever we would all like to do. Ok with you?” I nod in agreement and sis gets up and goes into the kitchen.
I look over at Amanda and say, “Amanda, I truly am sorry for making you feel bad and misunderstanding. Would you come with me?” She has regained her composure now and looks at me and asks, “are you sure…” I look at her and say, “yes, come with me”. And smiled at her. She decided that I was sincere and got up and I took her hand and we slipped past the kitchen and into the bedroom at the back of the apartment.
When we get in there, I see that sis has already gotten everything cleaned up and packed away and the little light is on that sits on the nightstand. I take the cue and close the door gently and turn off the light. Once again, its soft glow pushes out just enough that the bed can be seen. I look at Amanda and ask her, “would you like to just lay on the bed and talk for a few minutes first?” She nods in agreement and we go and lay on the bed…remembering how sis relaxed me I laid with my head on her legs turned towards her and we started to talk about what had happened earlier in the evening and she apologized again for hitting me in the face with that question about 2 hours after I met her. I told her not to worry about it and we continued to talk for a few minutes.
Just then I remembered that she asked sis a question in the car that made her jaw drop, so I figured might as well ask…”hey what was up with all that secret code talk and then your jaw dropped earlier on the ride home in the car…?” She got a little nervous again and I said, “you don’t have to tell me if you don’t want to…” She looked at me and said, “She told me back in freshman year that she would not allow anyone to have anal sex with her until you did…if you did not want to do it then she did not care about it…but she really wanted to try it, but only with you…that is why I was so surprised when she said yes”
Ok well that made sense now…I figured there were little things I was going to find out along the way since this seemed to be a topic of regular discussion between the two. She had not noticed until now, but I was rubbing my hand on the side of her very ample breasts and just kind of trying to get her to relax. She looked down at my hand and I think she got the idea I was really interested in her sexually after all, not just doing this because sis asked me to…
Leave a Reply