Twin Seduction

Literotic asexstories – Twin Seduction by Spinner_of_tails,Spinner_of_tails
Hello my beautiful readers. This is a story that I’ve spent the last four years trying to write. There is some truth to what really happened in what you’re about to read, and I guess that might be what has kept me from letting the world know. Just how much of this story is true though is between me and my conscience, and the names of those involved have been altered for their privacy. As always, anyone engaging in a sexual act is of legal age. Oh, and this story differs from my usual work in that there is a hint of bisexuality between two guys in this story, so if you’re easily offended, I suggest you close the browser.

Enjoy.

Xoxo

/Anna

****

You might say this story is a confession of sorts. Even though what has happened easily could be considered wrong, it has made me feel better about myself. In doing so, I’d like to think that it’s made me a better person. I guess you could bring up that old “the road to hell is paved with good intentions,” but I don’t want to bore you with a long-winded discussion on morality. Let me instead begin my introducing myself.

My name is Anna, and I’m a 20 year old college graduate. I graduated from high school at 15, finished a 4 year college program at the age of 18, and spent the last year and a half taking some random courses in sociology, philosophy and politics. Yes, that’s correct. I’ve never had my intelligence accurately measured, but throughout my childhood, words like “genius” and “brainiac” were thrown my way.

I’m 5’7″ tall, with an average build, neither slim nor overweight, apart from my F-cup sized breasts that is. Those who manage to tear their eyes from my chest, will see that I have long blonde hair, blue-green eyes, and perfect skin.

“A busty blonde genius with flawless skin? Your life must be perfect, right?” I hear you ask.

Well, not really. It’s not always socially accepted for a girl to talk openly about being curious about sex, but my curiosity arose early. Sadly, it seems having large breasts makes a lot of young guys afraid to approach a girl, and I was nervous about the social stigma of being labeled a slut or whore if I was too forward. Attending classes where my fellow students were older than me added to my social awkwardness.

I did have one friend though. I met Sara my last semester in college, and even though she was 4 years older than me, we had enough in common to become close friends. We both loved (and still do) classical music, art and history, and spend many evenings discussing the ramifications of the French revolution. Sara is a tall, thin Irish girl, with long, cascading red hair. Even though we do spend many evenings chatting about this and that, she’s always had a wild streak about her, and she’s made many attempts to get me to join her on her wild adventures. I don’t know if I should be thankful that I wasn’t 18 at the time, but it kept me from joining her on the wildest of her schemes.

Soon after graduating from college, I met this guy, named Chris. He was a couple of years older than me, and I guess became quite smitten by his stories about how he’d grown up in Europe, and all the places he’d visited. We went out on a couple of dates and, as eventually wound up having sex. It wasn’t the earth shattering experience I had been led to believe it would be, but I enjoyed it. At first, it was a little bit exciting, and even though I had gone pretty far in my academic career, it still felt like taking the first steps into adulthood to experiment sexually.

Sadly the relationship didn’t last long. I guess I can go on and on about him being afraid of my intellect, but that’s not really why I’m telling this story. Besides, I think it also had something to do with me saying no to some of his wildest fantasies, a threesome with him and one of his female friends being one of them. What I guess I could say though is that being dumped didn’t help my social anxiety, and once more I returned to the safe, uncomplicated company of books.

Sara was (and to my knowledge still is) dating a guy called Todd, and after my breakup with Chris, she made several attempts to get me back on the dating scene. Mostly I said no, though I did go on two dates, one of which ended with us having sex. After a disappointing sexual encounter, the guy said he wasn’t looking for anything long term, so instead of whetting my appetite for further dates, it only made me retreat further into the world of books.

Why am I telling you all of this? Well, my reclusive behavior lasted about a year, and I think Sara became worried. I explained to her that she had nothing to worry about, but she clearly wasn’t ready to give up. She insisted on me coming over to her dorm room, and as I wasn’t legally allowed to drink, she bought us beers every time. I trusted Sara implicitly and tried beers a couple of times.

“At least Tolstoy doesn’t dump me for refusing a threesome with his friend,” I muttered bitterly to Sara one evening, during one of our evenings in her room. After that evening, I decided that alcohol brought out the worst in me, and I stopped drinking. In fact, I didn’t touch a drop until a few weeks ago, which is the reason for me writing this story.

****

It was a Tuesday. Sara and I were in her dorm room. We had just finished watching a documentary on the women of the French revolution, when Sara gave me a strange look. She then proceeded to drop a bomb on me, telling me she thought Todd was cheating on her. I had met Todd enough times to know he seemed like a stand-up guy, and one of the few “good ones,” so naturally I told her she had to be mistaken.

After a while of Sara venting her insecurities about Todd, and me consoling her, she looked up at me, as if coming up with the solution for cold fusion. She then told me that she was going away that weekend on some family business, and she begged me to go visit Todd at his house.

“Maybe even catching them in the act,” Sara told me with a face so serious it was almost comical.

“Sweetie,” I said calmly, looking deep into her bright green eyes. “What if I don’t catch him with someone? What if he’s not even there?” I asked, in my mind a rational thing to ask.

“He’s always at home during the weekends,” Sara said, starting to smile. “And if you don’t catch him,” she added, and I could almost see the cog wheels in her brain clicking. “At least then you’ll be there, and keep him from nailing some skank while I’m gone,” she continued. She did have a point with that last part, but I was still doubting the usefulness of her scheme. Besides, it had one major flaw in it.

“Ok,” I said, taking a deep breath, still looking deep into Sara’s eyes. “Let’s say I go over there, let’s say I don’t catch your boyfriend cheating, what then? What do I do? I mean, wouldn’t it be weird for me to come over, and then just stand there?” I asked calmly. Sara looked as if considering my words carefully, and then her eyes lit up once more.

“I’ll call him Saturday morning, and tell him that the power’s out in your place, so you’ll drop by, and stay the night because the power company won’t get things fixed until Sunday. Brilliant,” Sara said merrily, and to be honest, it was hard to keep myself from being drawn into her enthusiasm. It was just her way, to drag me into her schemes. I considered her idea for a moment, and even though I seriously doubted anything would come out of it, I guessed it wouldn’t hurt to spend an evening somewhere other than Sara’s dorm room or the public library.

“Fine, I’ll do it,” I said eventually, and Sara cheered.

****

Saturday. So, today I was supposed to catch Sara’s boyfriend, huh? I had already showered that morning, but for some reason I decided to have a quick shower, before leaving for Todd’s place. I put on a white shirt and a short, bright red skirt, and as I looked at myself in the mirror, I couldn’t help but feel silly about this whole idea. What was I really supposed to be doing there? What If he really was cheating on Sara, and just decided to meet the girl at some other place? Was I supposed to follow him if he left the apartment? I sent Sara a text, letting her know I was heading over to Todd’s place, and left. I decided to pack a bag and brought along a textbook, just in case.

I rang Todd’s doorbell, and at first glance I thought it was Todd opening the door. Todd just turned 30 the other week, and he is around 6 feet tall and. From what I have seen at the beach, Todd has a swimmer’s body. He had shortcut, dark brown hair, and really friendly dark green eyes. If you asked me to, I guess I’d describe him as a tall, dark, handsome stranger. Except that last “stranger” part, I’d met him with Sara enough times to get to know him a little.

Yet, this clearly wasn’t Todd. He looked very much like him, but there were a few subtle differences. Todd usually has a stubble, but this guy was clean-shaven. Todd also has a birthmark just over his left eyebrow, which this guy lacked. It took me half a second, before coming to the conclusion that this guy had to be Todd’s twin brother, a guy I hadn’t met before. Todd’s apparent twin brother was wearing a pair of white slacks, and a worn Nirvana-t-shirt that was tight enough to hint at the same swimmers body as Todd had.

“Hi. I’m Anna,” I said and smiled. “Is Todd home?” I asked, and I could see the guy smiling.

“Wow, that was fast,” the guy replied. “I’m Adam, Todd’s twin brother,” he added, holding out his hand. “Todd is in the living room,” Adam continued, as I shook his hand. Adam then stepped aside. As I stepped past him a part of me wondered if Sara’s suspicions might just be based on a misunderstanding. If someone had seen who they thought was Todd with another girl, perhaps it had been Adam? I stored this nugget of information in the back of my head, deciding to discuss it with Sara at some other time.

I walked in to the living room, where Todd was sitting on a large sofa. He was also wearing a pair of white slacks and a Metallica t-shirt.

“Hey there, Anna,” Todd said smiling up at me as I entered the room, gesturing for me to join in on the sofa. “Sara told me there was an issue with the power in your apartment, and you needed a place to crash for the night,” he said softly.

“Yeah, I called the power company, and they said they should have it fixed by tomorrow,” I replied, remembering the lie Sara had come up with to excuse me hanging around Todd’s place for the night. I sat down on the sofa next to Todd, and Adam joined us, sitting down in a chair next to me. It felt a little awkward to be there.

I mean, I knew Todd enough to feel comfortable around him, but with Adam around as well, I didn’t want them to have to change whatever they had planned for the evening. If I’m being completely honest with you, I guess I should admit that I always found Todd quite attractive, and hanging out with two versions of him felt strange.

“No worries, sweet cheeks,” Todd said in his usual suave, friendly manner. “I have a spare room, and I’ve made a bed for you to crash in,” he added with a smile that only added to the uneasy feeling inside me. For a split-second, I had to remind myself that I was there on a mission for my friend.

“So, what do you guys have planned for the evening?” I said, to keep the silence from becoming awkward, looking at Adam and then back at Todd.

“Well, we don’t exactly have any firm plans for the evening,” Todd replied, looking over at Adam. “We were just talking about maybe having a few beers and watching a football game,” he added.

“You a football fan?” Adam asked. I swallowed to keep from giggling. I had always found sports to be interesting, but more out of a group psychological stand point. I doubted though that Todd and Adam were interested in hearing me analyze a football game, so instead of going on about my views, I shook my head.

“Not really, no. I’ve never been much for sports,” I replied, again feeling like I was intruding on their guys night. I was about to tell them that I wouldn’t mind just going to Todd’s guest room and reading for a couple of hours, when I saw Adam’s eyes light up.

“Then how about we all play a game or something?” Adam said. “How about a game of never have I ever?” he asked before either Todd or I could ask him what he had in mind. I had only played that particular game once before, since I wasn’t legally allowed to drink alcohol and, from what I knew, the game basically revolved around admitting embarrassing facts about yourself by drinking.

“Anna’s only 20 years old,” Todd said. “I’m guessing she hasn’t had much experience with heavy drinking like you and me,” he added, and they both chuckled. I wasn’t offended by what Todd had said, and he was correct. Legally, I wasn’t old enough to drink alcohol, though I had tried beer a couple of times before.

“I guess we can play that game,” I replied. For some reason though, I didn’t want to feel like a child in the company of adults, and my reply seemed to make Adam and Todd happy. “Though, Todd is correct. I’m not used to drinking all that much. Maybe I could just take a sip, instead of drinking the entire glass?” I hurried to add. As I said, I did have a secret attraction to Todd, and the last thing I wanted to do was to make a fool of myself by becoming so drunk I lost control of my faculties. Besides, I needed to keep all my wits if I was to report back to Sara about what had happened tonight.

“Sounds fair,” Todd said, and Adam brought out three glasses, filling them with beer. I took a deep breath as I grabbed my glass. Both Todd and Adam smiled as they grabbed their glasses, and I smiled back as I realized this might be a chance to get Todd to answer if he had even been unfaithful to Sara. I just needed to wait for the perfect opportunity. Besides, if I felt that I had drunk too much, I was perfectly able to stop drinking and stumble my way down the hall to the guest room they had prepared for me. Little did I know what I had just gotten myself into.

“I guess I can start,” Todd said and I took a deep breath. From my experience, drinking games like this one, usually devolved into questions about sex. “Never have I ever stolen fruit from a neighbor’s tree,” Todd said with a mischievous grin as he looked over at Adam. I could help but laugh as both Adam and Todd took a sip of their beers.

“I can see we’re off to a flying start,” Adam said, and they both laughed. I felt the earlier awkwardness washing away, instantly feeling more comfortable hanging out with both Adam and Todd.

Todd looked expectantly at me, and my mind spun for a split-second as I tried to come up with something funny to say.

“Never ever have I kissed a guy,” I said before I could stop myself. To this day I don’t know what made me say that. I barely had time to lift my glass to my mouth though, before I saw both Adam and Todd lift their glasses and take a sip. I looked at them with must have been shock, but Todd just gave me a casual shrug of his shoulders.

“Sara dared me and Adam to kiss at a party once,” he said calmly. “She thought it’d be sexy to watch her boyfriend to kiss himself,” he added, and I tried to hide my embarrassment by giggling. In hindsight though, Sara had been correct, and for a split-second I allowed the mental image to linger in my mind, before forcing it away. I felt my cheeks blushing, and turned to look at Adam, to draw attention away from the heat in my face.

“Never have I ever spent time in a library after closing hours,” Adam said after a moment’s thought. They both looked expectantly at me, and I blushed ever harder as I took a sip from my beer. Todd and Adam chuckled, and I played it off by imitating Todd’s casual shrugging of his shoulders. All eyes then turned to Todd, who smiled back at us.

“Never ever have I read more than one book in a week,” he said. Again I took a sip of my beer, and I had a nagging suspicion that it was directed at me.

“I thought you knew that I’m a brainiac?” I asked Todd with a big smile. I could feel that the alcohol was starting to affect me, and I knew I had to tread carefully to keep from getting drunk off my feet.

“Oh no,” Todd said and held up his hands in mock surrender. “I’ve always appreciated your brains and your sense of humour,” he added with a disarming smile. In hindsight, I should have understood that he was flirting with me, but the warmth of the friendly atmosphere and the alcohol blinded me to that obvious fact.

I knew I would need to get Todd to drink a little more, before I might get him to admit any infidelity, and decided to hold off on that question for now. There was a faint but definite buzzing sensation spreading throughout my body, and I couldn’t stop smiling. A part of me wondered why I had been so nervous about spending time with Todd, and for the first time in a long time, I felt free to act a little crazy.

“Never ever have I stripped naked in public,” I said and again I wondered to myself why I had said that. Hadn’t I planned to make statements that would make Todd drink? I hadn’t expected a reaction from Todd or Adam, and I laughed so hard I almost spilled my beer, when I saw Adam take a sip from his glass.

“What?” Adam said, as if he had just admitted to the most normal thing in the world. “I did it on Todd’s college, and you wouldn’t believe the shit storm that followed,” he added.

“The principal wasn’t amused,” Todd said, making me laugh once more.

“Never ever have I aced all the tests in a single semester,” Todd said after we all had managed to calm down after Adam’s admission. I took a deep breath and took a sip of my beer. Now that one was clearly directed at me, and that might have been the point where I should have realized that I need to stop playing and head off to bed. I had only been really drunk once before in my life, and I had yet to learn where my limits where. Even though I felt comfortable with Adam and Todd, I didn’t know drunk Anna enough to know how it would affect my behaviour.

“You’re trying to get me so drunk that I’ll agree to watch football with you two, aren’t you?” I asked Todd, and again he held his hands up in mock surrender.

“No, no,” he said calmly. “I know you’re smarter than me and Adam put together. I just wanted to know just how smart you are,” Todd added, again with that disarming, charming smile. Once again, I should have read the signs, and seen that he was flirting, but again I mistook it for friendly banter.

“Well, I’ve never had my intelligence accurately measured,” I told him. “But yeah, I am a genius,” I added before I could stop myself. I instantly regretted saying that. Was there a reason that I was trying to show my best qualities to Todd? Did my attraction to him run deeper than I wanted to admit?

“Never have I ever been in love,” Adam said after a brief pause. I think I had been in love with Chris, so I took a sip of my beer. From the corner of my eye, I caught Todd taking a sip as well. I smiled inwardly, thinking he had to be thinking about Sara. Guys don’t cheat on girls that they’re in love with right? With every passing minute, I began to doubt Sara’s suspicions more and more, and I got a warm feeling inside about the report I’d make to her the next day. By now I was definitely buzzed from the alcohol, but also from the warm feeling I got from Todd and Adam. These really were two of the good guys. I took a deep breath, deciding to finally pop the question.

“Never ever have I been unfaithful,” I said softly, and my heart skipped a beat as I saw Todd not sipping his beer. The warm feeling inside increased, and a part of me wanted to text Sara, to let her know that her suspicions were unfounded. It might be considered rude to interrupt our game to text someone though, so I refrained from picking up my phone for now.

“Never ever have I had a threesome,” Todd said, after refilling his and Adam’s glasses, with a mischievous grin as he looked over at Adam. Both of them raised their glasses and sipped their beer. I didn’t mean to, but for some reason I raised my glass and took a sip as well. Conditioned response, perhaps? Both Adam and Todd looked at me with genuine surprise in their eyes.

“Oh, sorry guys. No I haven’t had a threesome,” I said and giggled. “I guess the beer is getting to my head,” I hurried to add.

“Anyone ever ask you to participate in one?” Adam asked with a wide grin. I guessed my earlier assessment was true, and these kinds of drinking games really did tend to revolve around sex. I blushed and looked down into my glass. I really did feel surprisingly comfortable with Adam and Todd, and I again I didn’t want to come off as a prude or juvenile, so I took a deep breath before answering.

“Yeah,” I said, without looking up. “My last boyfriend wanted to have a threesome with me and this other girl he knew. It might not just have been my eagerness to avoid sounding like a prude, and might also be that it still stung that Chris had dumped me, as a part of me was eager to change the topic, or at least divert the attention from me. I looked up at Todd, and remembered he and Adam had also taken a sip after Todd’s statement.

“How about you? Was your… experience.. with Sara?” I asked him, managing to smile back at him, and Todd nodded.

“Yeah, she and I were joined by one other guy,” he said casually. For a split-second, I was once more taken aback by how handsome he was, and I swallowed hard to keep from thinking what a threesome with him and another guy might be like. The rational part of my brain was screaming at me that I was treading dangerous waters now, and it was telling me to end the game. Right here. Right now.

“Never ever have I owned a library card,” Todd said calmly, a mischievous smile on his lips, before that rational part of my brain had time to make me realize what was happening. There was a subtle tingling sensation spreading throughout my body, and that sensation told me to go with the flow and see where the evening would go. It wasn’t a conscious decision, but I let myself go with that latter option.

“Now I know you’re trying to get me drunk,” I said to Todd. The mischievous smile was still splitting his face, and I couldn’t help but smile back. To this day I’m not sure why I did it, but in response to his statement, I winked at him before lifting my glass and took a sip of my beer.

Did I mention that I didn’t have much experience with alcohol? The alcohol was definitely starting to affect my judgement, and by now I was feeling a really pleasing buzzing feeling. The warmth of the buzz only added to the tingling sensation, reaffirming the subconscious decision to see the night through. I was still sober enough though to realize I was quickly approaching the limit of how much I was able to drink and remain in control of myself.

“I think I’m going to have to stop drinking soon guys,” I said to the both of them, blushing again. A part of me didn’t want the evening to end, but I didn’t want to force these nice guys to have to deal with a girl drunk out of her mind.

“How about we play a game of truth or dare instead?” Adam asked, and as I looked over at him, I saw the same mischievous grin on his face as Todd. I know I should have said no and gone to bed. I knew enough to know for sure that it was a game where you eventually chose a dare, and that those dares would inevitably turn inappropriate. I found myself wanting to spend more time with Adam and Todd though. I guess I could blame the alcohol lowering my inhibitions, but if I was hones with myself, I just didn’t want the evening to end. If I’m even more honest with myself, the tingling sensation hadn’t subsided, and the rational part of my mind would describe the sensation as arousal. Consequently, I nodded, agreeing with Adam’s suggestion. Both Adam and Todd had shit eating grins on their faces, as Todd looked over at Adam.

“Let’s begin softly. I chose truth,” Adam said confidently.

“Ever fucked someone you shouldn’t have?” Todd asked. A soft beginning indeed. The rational fear I had about questions inevitably turning sexual was clearly well-founded, but Adam took it all in stride, and shook his head before turning to look at me.

“Truth,” I said shyly. Even though I felt comfortable with these guys, I was sober enough to think that perhaps I shouldn’t be the one to chose dare first.

“Ever wanted to fuck someone you shouldn’t?” Adam asked, and that confident shit eating grin never left his face. I blushed harder than I had in a long time, and I shook my head, afraid to speak, lest my voice broke. Then I took a sip of my beer to calm myself and took a deep breath, before turning to look at Todd.

“Dare me,” Todd said calmly, looking deep into my eyes. Damn, why did he have to have such a handsome, daring look in his eyes.

“I dare you,” I began, and I was beginning to consciously realize that I was putting on a show for Adam and Todd. I realized a part of me wanted Todd to know there was more to me than a pretty face and a smart brain. “I dare you to kiss your brother on the lips,” I added, instantly regretting my rashness.

I couldn’t spot even a hint of hesitation in Todd’s face though, as he stood up and walked over to Adam.

“I guess if we did it for Sara, we could do it for Anna,” Todd said, and they both grinned as Todd leaned down, planting a kiss on Adam’s lips. The kiss only lasted a quick moment, but I had never seen anything like it before, and to be completely honest, it was the hottest thing I had ever seen. I blushed as I admitted that fact to myself, and that I finally admitted to myself that the tingling sensation in fact was arousal. Ok, so if nothing else happened that evening, at least I had learned that I found the sight of two guys kissing arousing Todd then walked back to sit down beside me, as if nothing had happened, and I silently wished someone would turn down the heat in the apartment.

Todd then looked at Adam expectantly.

“Dare me,” Adam said without hesitation. So, the truth section of the game was over now? Was it simply a game of daring each other to outdo each other with embarrassing acts?

“I dare you to kiss Anna on the lips,” Todd said, and both Adam and I looked at Todd with quizzical looks.

“What the hell, dude,” Adam said, clearly uncomfortable with Todd putting me in that situation. Against my better judgement, I put a hand on Adam’s leg and looked over at him with a smile.

“Hey. It’s ok. We have ample time to get back at him later in the game,” I said, not quite believing that I was saying it, but I had evidently made a subconscious choice to go along with it. Adam looked at me for a moment, and then that confident smile returned. He leaned in closer and placed a warm, soft kiss on my lips. It was over in a heartbeat, but I swore I sensed Adam wanting to part his lips to put his tongue in my mouth. My head was spinning, and I couldn’t quite believe that I had just kissed someone I had just met, and an older guy at that. I quickly recovered though, desperate to hide the embarrassed look in my face. Why, oh why hadn’t I gone to bed? Adam looked at me, seemingly calmed by the fact that I hadn’t freaked out about his kiss.

I took a deep breath, composing myself before speaking.

“I guess this game is all about daring each other now huh? Dare me,” I said with a confidence I didn’t know I had in me.

“Well, to be honest,” Adam began, and I saw a mischievous look in his eyes. Oh, no. “I don’t think it’s fair that only I get to kiss you, Anna. I dare you to kiss Todd,” Adam calmly added. So, the game really was afoot now. In for a penny, in for a pound, as they say. I wanted to say that there was no way I was backing out now.

Again I had to be honest with myself, and admit that it felt like everything up to now had been building up to this. As I turned to look at Todd, I finally admitted to myself that I had been wanting to kiss him for a long time.

For a split-second I thought about Sara, reminding myself that I had come there on a mission, but my libido managed to rationalize it as ‘merely a kiss’. I had even kissed Sara once, so where was the harm in kissing her boyfriend?

Todd was sitting right next to me, so there really was no reason for what I did next. Some part of me wanted this though, so I stood up and walked in front of Todd. He looked up at me with a huge grin on his face. I smiled back at him as I slowly lowered myself onto his lap. To his credit, he never even looked at my large breasts, even though they were close to being mashed against his face. Instead, he kept his eyes on mine, as I slowly lowered my face to his. I pressed my lips against his, and the tingling sensation in my body increased exponentially as I felt him kiss me back. I felt myself wanting to open my mouth, to push my tongue into his mouth, and it took a supreme effort of will to break off the kiss. As I did, I realized I had placed my hands on his cheeks without even knowing it.

I bit my lower lip to keep from blushing as I tore away my hands from his face.

The rational part of my mind that had been screaming at me to stop playing, and to head off to bed, was a faint whisper by now, but I still knew that we were well on our way to passing a point of no moral return, if we hadn’t done so already.

“I guess we shouldn’t tell Sara about this,” I said, blushing hard as I heard the arousal in my own voice. Todd never said anything in response, instead smiling up at me.

“Truth or dare, Anna?” he asked calmly. Wait, wasn’t it my turn to ask him? I looked at him quizzically, but the look in his eyes told me he expected an answer.

“Dare me,” I replied before I could turn to Adam for support regarding the order of questions.

“I dare you to sit in my lap for the next round,” Todd said without hesitation. Well, that one was easy enough. I was already sitting in his lap, so sure. I stood up and turned around though, so I could look over at Adam, before sitting back down in Todd’s lap.

“Well, Adam? Truth or dare?” I asked, thankful that my arousal wasn’t as evident in my voice anymore.

“Dare me,” Adam said, and even though he sounded confident, there was a definite hint of nervousness in his voice. As you might have realized, I had always been a ‘good girl’, and never really let my hair down. I hadn’t had a wild streak, but sitting there, in the lap of my best friend’s boyfriend, slightly buzzed, and definitely arousal, I think I finally felt free to do and say exactly what I wanted. There were no societal pressure for me to perform at me best. I was finally allowed to just be Anna. In hindsight, there’s no doubt in my mind that my arousal was affecting my judgement as I decided to take the game up a notch.

“I dare you to lose that Nirvana t-shirt,” I said with a huge grin, and Adam barely hesitated before pulling his t-shirt up and over his head. I bit my lower lip, praying that he couldn’t see the blush in my face as I looked at his impressive abs, perhaps longer than I should have. I guess I at least got confirmation that Adam was as well built as I knew Todd to be.

Thankfully Adam stopped looking at me, and turned his head to look over my shoulder at Todd, who spoke before Adam could even ask the question.

“Dare me,” I heard Todd say, and again there was no hesitation in Adam’s voice as he spoke.

“I dare you to do a belly shot off of Anna’s belly,” Adam said.

“Really, bro?” Todd replied, a little too fast. In hindsight, I should have realized the quickness of their responses meant something. I should have read the easy nature with which Adam and Todd escalated things, as if it was a practiced routine. I had never heard of this phenomenon before, and I think Adam read the confused look in my face.

“A belly shot is where Todd pours beer into your belly button, and then suck it up,” Adam explained. Again, I knew the aroused part of my brain was speaking for me, but it sounded like fun.

“I’m up for it, if you are?” I said, turning my head to look at Todd, who looked pleasantly surprised by my question. The shit eating grin on his face told me he wasn’t going to back out of the dare, so we both stood up, and then I lay down on the sofa. As I unbuttoned the bottom buttons on my shirt, I couldn’t help but giggle when I realized that my breasts were so large that I couldn’t see what Adam and Todd would be doing. Todd then kneeled beside the sofa, and grinned up at me.

“Here goes,” he said and his face disappeared out of my line of sight. I felt something wet being poured onto my belly, and the tingling sensation from the liquid only added to my arousal, though I was too far gone to ponder any moral implications about what we were doing. Todd quickly put his lips against my belly, and I’m not ashamed to admit that I bit my lower lip to keep from letting out a slight moan. I’m not sure how much I would have protested if either one of them would have started to caress me at that point. As I sat back up, both Adam and Todd looked at me with their almost trademark mischievous grins.

“What?” I asked, curious to know if I had done something to inspire such mirth.

“I guess you couldn’t tell, but when you parted your shirt, both Todd and I could see what a pretty bra you have on,” Adam said, nodding at my breasts.

“Well, I guess a bra isn’t all that much more revealing than a bikini,” I said, thinking out loud, and then looking at Todd. “You’ve seen me in a bikini, so there wasn’t anything you hadn’t seen before,” I added. Of course bras are part of a woman’s lingerie, and implicitly more intimate than a bikini, but I doubt no one in the room were interested in a discussion on levels of intimacy at that time.

“In that case, I dare you to take off your shirt,” Adam said without hesitation. As I looked into their eyes, I could see definite hints of the same arousal that was slowly rising within me. In not sure if it was for my sake, but I still couldn’t help but smile, thinking that they were willing to keep up the pretense of still actually playing a game of truth or dare. There was no longer any doubt in my mind that something was going to happen tonight, and I’m willing to bet that they could read the aroused look in my eyes. Being the least experienced person in the room, I was immensely thankful for them taking it slow, giving me time to wrap my mind around the fact that something was going to happen. What though? I had no idea, but I was sure that I should go with the flow and enjoy whatever happened.

With a confidence I didn’t know I had in me, I rose up. For some reason, I decided to shake my hips from side to side, imitating a stripper’s dance as I finished unbuttoning my shirt, before casually flinging it towards Adam. Both guys applauded my little act, making me blush.

“My, that bra looks really soft,” Todd said calmly, and by now they were openly staring at my breasts, though I really didn’t care. I was the center of their attention, and the rising tingling sensation between my legs told me that I loved every second of it.

“I dare you to feel just how soft it is,” I told Todd, not really caring about how my voice clearly betrayed how turned on I was. As if waiting for his cue, Todd took a step closer, and I closed my eyes in anticipation as he lay hands on my bra.

“Mmmm.. Feels wonderful,” Todd whispered, though whether he was talking about the fabric of my bra or my breasts were unclear. I doubt anyone in the room cared about that very distinction though. He kept his hands there for a moment, before giving my breasts a subtle squeeze. I let out a gasp, and looked up at him. I guess I shouldn’t have been surprised by what he did, I practically (if not literally) dared him to, and as I looked up into his eyes, I saw a look that I had only seen a few times before, yet there was nothing subtle about it. His eyes told me he wanted to fuck me tonight, and I’m sure the look I gave him told him that I wanted it as well.

“I dare you to spend the next round sitting in Adam’s lap,” Todd said softly, and I gave him a wink as I slowly lowered myself onto Adam’s lap. Having long since dropped the pretense that this was anything other than foreplay, I found it pretty amusing for Todd to still use terms like ’round’. I felt Adam wrap his arms around me, placing his hands on to stomach, mere inches below my breasts. His hands were surprisingly soft, and my mind was starting to spin. The look in both their eyes shone with arousal, and everything about their body language screamed reluctant restraint. What had begun as a slight tingling sensation had been building slowly but inexorably, and as I looked up into Todd’s eyes and felt Adam’s hands on me, I just couldn’t take anymore.

Todd looked back down at me, and we looked deep into each other’s eyes. I could see the unspoken question in his lustful eyes. I opened my mouth to speak, knowing that this was the final barrier. What we had done so far had been taboo, and certainly inappropriate, but the next words I spoke would be damning.

“I dare you to kiss me the way you kiss Sara,” I said, my voice thick with desire. I guess I was so nervous about asking Todd to kiss me, that I barely realized that I had grabbed Adam’s hands, and placed them over my breasts. As Adam began to grope and caress my large breasts, Todd got down on one knee, coming close to being face to face with me. Our eyes met again, and we both knew that words weren’t necessary anymore. He leaned in closer and our lips met.

This time neither of us hesitated and as I opened my mouth, our tongues met, and began a passionate dance. His hunger matched mine as we made out, neither of us wanting to break off the kiss, even to breathe. I moaned into his mouth as I felt his hands caress my cheeks. Beside the obvious arousal of kissing a handsome guy, it felt immensely liberating to finally be allowed to admit to myself that I wanted it. I could finally admit that I had harbored a desire for my best friend’s boyfriend, and the liberating feeling of that admission only made the sensation of kissing him more of a turn on.

In fact, I was so lost in the heavenly kiss that I couldn’t even tell if it was Adam or Todd who unclasped my bra. I didn’t really care who it was though, and fumbled with trying to keep making out with Todd while helping them free my breasts from their confines.

Eventually both Todd and I had to breathe, and we reluctantly broke off the kiss. I saw the same look of animal lust in Todd’s eyes. My lack of experience made me hesitant as to what to do next though, but thankfully Todd took the lead. He stood up, and unzipped his pants, letting them and his boxers fall to the floor around his feet. As he did so, I’m no expert on the size of guys’ cocks but being in the state I was, it seemed enormous, and it throbbed with excitement.

I looked up at Todd’s face, and I knew enough to realize what he wanted from me. I had only done it a few times though, and suddenly I became terrified about disappointing Todd with a lousy blow-job.

“Just go with what feels good to you,” Todd said softly, and the kind smile on his lips was encouraging. I took a deep breath to steady myself, when I suddenly felt one of Adam’s hands leaving my breasts, and making its way down under my skirt. Oh, that’s right. I had been so lost in making out with Todd, and the prospect of sucking his cock, that I had almost forgotten about Adam. It’s weird how your libido can mess with your cognitive skills and your perceptions, huh?

I could feel Adam wanting to finger me, and quickly reached down to unzip my dress with one hand, eager to assist him in any way I could, even as I wrapped my other hand around Todd’s shaft. I could feel it throb under my touch, as if I could feel his heartbeat. I opened my mouth as wide as I could, and then wrapped my lips around the tip. I saw Todd close his eyes and lean his head backwards, silently enjoying my touch. I slowly inched my head forward, and just as I did, Adam’s fingers found my slit, and began to caress my pussy with such skill that I couldn’t keep from moaning on Todd’s cock. If I hadn’t been so lost in the intense pleasure of moment I would have laughed at the improbability of what was happening. Never, in a million years, would I have guessed that I would find myself here, in the company of two of the most handsome, gentle guys, on my way to having my first threesome.

Yet here I was, slowly but inexorably pushing my head forward, letting Todd’s magnificent cock fill my mouth as Adam used his fingers to bring me more pleasure than any lover had before in my life.

As I pushed my head forward, I felt Adam grab my butt and lift me up. I wasn’t sure what was happening, but helped him raise me up. Then I felt his fingers pull my panties aside, before he lowered me again. I pulled my head back and gasped as I felt something hard poke against my pussy lips. I looked up into Todd’s eyes, and he just smiled down at me knowingly. I opened my mouth to speak, but the pleasure was so intense that I could only gasp. Evidently Adam had unzipped his pants and pulled out his cock, and his thick shaft was now starting to impale me.

A part of me wanted to weep with joy. So this was what sex was supposed to feel like? I desperately wrapped my mouth around Todd’s cock again, eager to let him feel the same level of pleasure that I was experiencing. I tried to move my hips up and down on Adam’s amazing shaft, but the sensation was so powerful that I wasn’t able to move my head back and forth on Todd’s cock. I felt Adam’s hands on my butt, holding me up, so I let him set the pace. I was quickly becoming delirious with arousal, as Adam started to fuck me, his thrusts gathering speed. I wrapped my hand around Todd’s throbbing cock, and mine and Adam’s moans filled the room. I tried to make myself suck Todd’s cock, but I couldn’t bring myself to focus on moving my head back and forth.

“Oh god… uh… uh.. Fuck… uh.. Fuck my face,” I managed to utter, looking up at Todd, my eyes glazed with desperation to feel him back inside me, but Todd surprised me by pulling off his t-shirt, and then lay down on the sofa instead.

Adam clearly understood what was happening and slowed down his thrusts, and our moans eventually silenced. It took me a moment to understand what Todd wanted, but he lay down on his back, and looked deep into my eyes as he motioned for me to come to him. He didn’t need to speak though, as my horny mind eventually understood that he wanted me to ride his hard cock.

I was reluctant to stand up, meaning that Adam’s lovely cock would be pulled out. Knowing that I wouldn’t be empty of cock for long though, I stood up, and Adam helped me pull down my skirt and panties.

With an eagerness born out of desperation, I quickly straddled Todd’s hips, and placed my hands on his strong chest. He looked at me with eyes full of a mix of lust and warmth, as he grabbed his cock and slowly helped me lower myself onto his shaft. I let out a loud moan as I felt him inside me, and again I wanted to speak. I opened my mouth, but no words would come out. My brain couldn’t formulate the words for what I was experiencing as Todd’s cock slowly filled my desperate pussy.

Todd then grabbed my butt and slowly raised me up. For a split-second I became mortally afraid that he’d push me up so far that his cock would pull out completely, but thankfully he stopped just as the tip was threatening to come out.

He held me still for a moment with one hand, and his other hand reached up to caress my cheeks. His touch was so tender, and his eyes showed such love and care that I wanted to weep.

I was so focused on Todd’s attention that I barely registered Adam coming up behind me, but I could feel Adam squirting some unknown liquid onto my ass.

“Sshhh… This might hurt, Anna,” Todd said in a soft voice. “I promise you that the pain will dissipate, and before you know it, the pain will be replaced by a feeling unlike anything you’ve felt before,” he added, and through the haze of arousal it dawned on my what was happening.

I was about to lose my anal virginity.

I opened my mouth to speak, to plead with him to stop this, but I immediately stopped myself. The look of love and care in Todd’s eyes gave away the truth of his words. Besides, I knew with every fiber of my being that this was what I wanted. I wanted to give myself to Adam and Todd. Completely. Without restraint.

Todd held me still, the tip of his cock inside my pussy. Up to that moment, being fucked in the butt was easily top three of the things I feared most about sex, but even as I took a deep breath to calm myself, I looked down into Todd’s eyes. I could feel the tip of Adam’s cock poking against my butt, knowing that this was the make or break moment, and Todd must have seen the worried look in my eyes as he smiled up at me.

Todd caressed my cheeks lovingly, helping me relax as I felt Adam’s tip force itself inside me. Todd had been correct, in that the sensation hurt, but as I opened my mouth again to scream out in pain, all I could hear was myself moaning.

Adam took things slow as he pushed himself inside me. I almost wept from the loving care he showed, as centimeter after centimeter of his cock filled me. I had never felt so full in my life, and a part of me was terrified that there was too much cock inside me and that they’d tear my insides apart. I had not idea if Adam’s cock was too big for my ass after all. It had certainly felt enormous when he had thrust it into my pussy moments before.

“He’s doing it… He’s doing it… Fuck… My ass.. He’s fucking my ass,” I stuttered, as much to Todd as myself. The pain in my butt was making me delirious, and I wasn’t sure if I could take much more, though I was in no state to protest.

“Sssshh,” Todd, said softly, pulling my head down, planting a kiss on my lips, as if to distract me from the pain in my butt. My mind was quickly going into sensory overload, and a part of me wanted to laugh out loud. Todd and Adam were literally fucking my brains out. It felt like every nerve ending in my body was on fire. My hands were resting on Todd’s shoulders, helping me remain upright, and I could feel every millimeter of his skin on my fingers. I could feel my heavy breasts resting on Todd’s chest, and the touch of my stiff nipples grazing his skin added fuel to the raging fire that was my arousal.

As Todd’s lips met mine, I could feel his cock thrusting upwards, caressing the insides of my pussy. Adam stopped pushing forward, keeping his throbbing shaft inside my butt, thankfully giving my body time to adjust to its sheer size. Todd ever so slowly started moving back and forth inside me, and even with my limited experience I had the presence of mind to realize what was happening.

As I felt Todd’s tongue in my mouth, it was all quickly becoming too much for me, and I could see stars dance in front of my eyes, and for the first time in my life, I was feeling the growing rush of an orgasm that wasn’t self-induced.

I wanted to scream, to let the whole world know of the pleasure these two guys were giving me. Todd’s passionate kiss, and the two cocks inside me were all that mattered to me at that moment, and just as Todd had said, the pain in my butt abated, replaced by pleasure beyond words.

I broke off kissing Todd, and looked down at him. As our eyes met, I could see the same look of pleasure in his eyes that I was feeling. I opened my mouth to speak, but no words came out. It was too late for words, and I felt my body starting to tremble as the orgasm washed over me. A faint part of me felt my pussy and my ass clench around Adam’s and Todd’s cocks, and I could hear their moans, but I was too lost in my own orgasm to register if they were moving at all.

“AAAAaaaahhhh… FUUUUUUUUUCK,” I screamed and closed my eyes, wanting desperately to feel them use me as the fuck-toy I was in that moment, knowing that it would prolong the heavenly feeling filling my entire being. I could feel Adam tightening his grip on my hips, moments before thrusting hard and deep into my butt.

“Holy fuck. Her ass is clenching so hard on my cock,” I heard Adam grunt, as he began to move back and forth.

“Her pussy too, bro,” Todd grunted back. “I told you she’d be an awesome fuck,” he added. If I’d had any presence of mind at that moment I would have wondered what he meant, but right then and there, he could have told me the world was ending, and it wouldn’t have changed a thing. As Adam began to pull back, I felt Todd thrusting up deeper inside me, and they began to sync their thrusts, so when Todd pulled back down from my pussy, Adam thrust forward into my butt and when Adam pulled back, Todd thrust up deeper inside me. I was nothing more than a piece of meat for their cocks, and the though made me delirious with joy. Every thrust prolonged the aftershocks of my orgasm, and the room was filled with loud moans from all of us.

“FUUUUUUCK! I’M GONNA FUCKING CUM!” Adam screamed, and it felt like he thrust so deep inside me that his cock was going to burst out from my chest.

“ME TOO, BRO!” Todd added a split-second after. “Let’s fill her up,” he added, and he followed suit, thrusting his cock as deep inside me as he could.

“AAAAAAAAAAAAHHHhhhh,” I yelled from the top of my lungs, the two cocks inside me so hard and so thick that it felt like I was about to be torn apart from the inside.

I opened my eyes, and looked down into Todd’s eyes. I wanted to say something. I wanted to beg them to fill me, to cum inside me and plaster my insides with their loads. I opened my mouth as my brain tried to find the right words. A millisecond later I felt their cocks swelling inside me, just before spurt after spurt of cum began to shoot out. The sensation of their simultaneous orgasms and the look of pleasure in Todd’s eyes became too much, and just as I thought I would be able to come down from the orgasmic high, it struck me again.

The second orgasm struck with the force of a thunderbolt, and I have no idea if I screamed. All I remember is an overwhelming tremor gathering in intensity as it spread from my pussy, and when it reached my head, I blacked out.

It was as if the world outside became a distant emptiness, and I felt myself drifting in a pink mist of unbridled pleasure, weeping with joy.

****

I slowly came to, and the world of the living forced itself back into my consciousness. To this day I couldn’t say if I was out for a second or an hour, but as my senses returned, I found myself still laying on top of Todd. A part of me was sad to feel empty as I realized both Adam and Todd had pulled their cocks out. There was a slight throbbing sensation in my butt, and the cum slowly running from my ass and my pussy was a stark reminder of what had happened.

I opened my eyes and looked deep into Todd’s eyes, and that shit eating grin from earlier had returned.

“Shit, Anna. We became worried when you screamed and fell unconscious,” I heard Adam say beside me. I turned my head to look up, seeing him standing beside the sofa offering me a bottle of water. I shook my head, smiling at him.

As I saw his slowly deflating cock, the thought of what I had just done came back to me, and I couldn’t hold back the tears from streaming down my face. I had just committed the ultimate betrayal. I had come on a mission to find out if Todd was cheating on Sara, and instead of fulfilling that mission, I had sucked his cock and let him and Adam fuck me senseless. Even the memory of the life altering orgasm couldn’t dissuade me from feeling like the worst friend in history.

“Sssshh, sweetie,” Todd said, and he and Adam sat me up on the sofa, sitting down on either side of me. It brought a weak smile on my face to see the concerned look on their faces.

“Did we hurt you?” Adam said, placing a hand on my leg, though there was nothing sexual about it, and it felt like the gentle touch of someone wanting to console me.

“No, it sure was rough,” I said with a sad smile as I looked at Todd. “But it was also the most pleasurable experience of my life. By the widest of margins,” I added, swallowing to keep a shiver of pleasure from overtaking me. I took a deep breath, quickly deciding that honesty was the best policy in a moment like this, even though I wasn’t sure how Todd would feel about what I was about to say.

After all, how do you tell a guy that his girlfriend thinks he I cheating on her, even sending her friend to check up on him? I turned my head to look at Todd.

“I haven’t been completely honest with you guys,” I said, trying to think of the best way to break the news to these two amazing guys. “There was never a problem with the power in my apartment,” I said after a moment’s silence.

“We know,” Todd said calmly, throwing me for a loop. What? How had he known? What was going on here? Todd chuckled, clearly amused by the surprised look on my face. I looked over at Adam, and he had the same amused look. I then turned back to look at Todd, and he held up a hand, as if wanting to explain himself.

“You see, Anna,” Todd began. “It was actually Sara who set this whole thing up. She told us that you were really broken up about Chris dumping you. Adam and I have shared Sara a couple of times, and she felt that if the opportunity arose, Adam and I should help you feel better about yourself in the best way we know how to,” Todd said softly.

I could feel my head spinning, and a mix of emotions flooded over me. I was still reeling from the feeling of guilt from fucking my best friend’s boyfriend, but the guilt was replaced by anger at Sara for conspiring behind my back. The anger quickly subsided as I realized that Sara had done this out of genuine concern for me, and I began to smile as a warm feeling overcame me. I guess we had never talked about how we felt for one another, but Sara clearly loved me enough to let her boyfriend fuck me. I had never experienced that level of trust with anyone before, and it was mind-blowing.

“Sara doesn’t have all that many close friends,” Todd continued after a moment’s silence. “I know that you’re the one she feels that she can always turn you, and for that fact alone, I love you Anna,” he added. I blinked several times, and had to swallow hard. I had always thought of Todd as a nice guy, sure, but I had never seen the side of him that would clearly do anything to make Sara happy.

“To be honest, I’ve wanted to fuck you for quite some time. Next to Sara, you’re one of the hottest girls I’ve ever met. I’d never fuck you without Sara’s explicit consent though,” Todd said, and I couldn’t help but giggle as I saw him actually blush. You’d think that sitting naked with two naked guys, both of whom you’ve just had sex with, would mean that there was little to be embarrassed about, but I saw the sincerity of his words. I turned to look at Adam who just smiled back at me.

“How about you?” I asked, grinning back at him.

“Todd’s told me quite a lot about you, so I know what an awesome person you are,” Adam said, and then glanced down at my breasts. “After tonight, I know that you’re not only an awesome person, but sexy as hell and an amazing fuck,” he continued, and placed a hand on my left breast giving it a playful squeeze.

“Listen guys,” I said looking into Adam’s eyes. “I love you both. Both for caring so much about the best friend I’ve ever had,” I said, and I saw Adam swallow hard as the emotion of the moment hit him as well. “But also for giving me the most intense fuck of my life,” I added playfully.

“So far,” Todd said, making us all laugh.

When the laughter died down, Adam explained that he had to go home, and from the reluctance of letting go of my breast, and getting dressed, I understood that he really did have something important to do.

I gave Adam a kiss goodbye on the lips before he left. Adam then showed me to the guest room, and he also got a goodnight kiss on the lips. I think we were both reluctant to end the kiss, but I was beyond exhausted, so thankfully we restrained ourselves, and he left to go to sleep in his own bedroom.

As I lay down on the bed, I grabbed my phone, thinking I’d better text Sara. I looked at the phone for the longest moment, not knowing what to write. Should I let her know that I knew about her plan? Should I say nothing?

In the end, I sent ‘I love you’, with a huge grin on my face. As I closed my eyes, I decided to talk to Todd the next morning, to plan a revenge on Sara.

The end…