Abby and Emily Ch. 03

In the afternoon Emily drove to the airport to bring Abby home.

I just finished giving a lecture about statistics.

I took a shower, put on a deodorant and clean clothes and was on the way to their home.

They were not home yet.

I grabbed the key from the hiding place and entered.

They were supposed to be back any moment, so I put the kettle on and waited.

I sat in the living room, recalling the last time I saw Abby.

It was in the airport on her way to Boston.

She kissed me hard and cried, “Brad my love, I miss you already! Don’t forget me… Once I finish college I’ll be back and we’ll plan our future life together!”

I remember gazing at her and thinking, ‘She is so young. We have no idea what will happen tomorrow and she thinks she knows what she’d want 3-4 years from now?…’

And then she boarded the plane.

So many things happened in these few months since she left – She found a new boyfriend/lover, who was abusive and used drugs… Her mother and I became romantically involved…

My thoughts got interrupted by a noise coming from the outside.

I heard the 2 women approaching the door and I opened it for them.

Abby entered first.

She looked skinnier and with longer hair then before, but still very attractive…

I kissed her cheek, “Abby, it’s nice to see you again. You look great!…”

She smiled, “Brad, you always were so nice to me. You try to compliment me, but we both know that you are lying. lately I was under a lot of stress and I hardly ate. I lost weight and my face is wrinkled like an old lady. But my hope is that I’ll feel better around here. I missed you a lot…”

Emily entered after Abby, “Brad, I wasn’t sure if you remembered the hiding place of the door key. Please help us carry Abby’s luggage from my car.”

It took me 3 trips from the car to bring all of Abby’s stuff.

She probably left nothing in Boston and was ready to start over in her former home.

As the 2 women went to freshen up, I prepared hot water and… waited.

Abby came out first, smiled and announced, “I need to see Lucy.”

“She and Buck play in the yard outside. You ought to know that she bosses Buck around and it’s not fair…”

Abby smirked, “You are so right! Lucy is so much bigger and stronger…”

We both laughed.

We knew each other so well, that I felt good about her ability to adjust to her former neighborhood and… me.

Abby looked me in the eye and mumbled, “Brad dear, you have no idea how much I missed ‘US’… I know that having my toxic relationship with another guy in Boston was inexcusable, but I still hope to rekindle what we had before…” Then she went through the back door to see Lucy.

Emily came out of her bedroom, “What did you think about Abby? She is tired, but she looks good, doesn’t she?”

“Darling, Abby went to the yard to say hello to Lucy, so we do not have a lot of time. She notified me that she wished we could go back to our previous relationship…”

Emily stared at me for a couple of minutes and then whispered, “What do YOU want?”

“Emily, I told you from day one that I still love Abby. However, nowadays I love you no less! The two of us need to think on the best way to tell her about our relationship and decide what to do next. Any other idea?”

With her face down she mumbled, “I love you and will hate to lose you… But I love my daughter too. So I guess it’s up to you to make up your mind…”

I smirked, “Just imagine how good it could be if I had a chance to have both of you!”

Emily smiled, “In Fantasyland?!…”

Abby entered and saw our smiles, “Brad, it makes me so happy that you kept in touch with mom. I still remember her being reluctant to talk or go outside. Now she behaves differently! She seems to be much happier. She even dresses much better… I assume that you had something to do with it. I owe you a lot and instead I cheated on you like an idiot… I like to think that I can prove myself worthy and have you as MORE than a friend again…”

I glanced at Emily. Her face was frozen…

“Abby, let’s go and eat something. I am famished. Your mother was so anxious waiting for you, that she skipped her last meal too. Emily, is there anything simple in this house, like pizza or pasta? Otherwise we’ll go out. Abby, on your first day you are our guest, so you choose…”

“Guys, like most students, in Boston I ate junk, so unless you want something else, Panera or Culvers are OK for me.”

“Emily, should we go by Abby’s selection, or your taste buds crave something else?”

“I don’t care. Panera is closer, so let’s go there.”

The dinner took about 1/2 an hour.

During that time Abby sounded cheerful and happy, while Emily was hardly talking.

I felt for her… Our relationship revived her physically and mentally and now, the arrival of her daughter was threatening to ruin her newly found love…

I was in a bind too – If I chose one, the other would be devastated, which would inevitably cause a rift between them as well.

They love each other and have no other family member to console ‘the loser’…

And I didn’t wish to choose between the two either!

A crazy idea started creeping into my mind.

It was insane, but I thought that we had nothing to lose…

“Girls, it’s Abby’s day and until tomorrow, whatever she wants – Goes!… But I hope that you remember that MY birthday is next weekend.”

Abby laughed, “I thought of mentioning it to mom once you left, so we decide what to buy for you…”

“Ladies, since it’s MY day, I’d like to celebrate it differently. I do not want presents. I’d like you two to forget all the previous troubles, from divorces to breakups, from mental anguish to financial issues. I wish us to be able to talk freely about everything and behave as if the outside world does not exist! I’ll bring good wine and want everybody to drink. If anybody is interested in weed, I can bring it also. Please…”

Abby jumped, “Count me in. I’d love to party with the two people I love so much!”

I stared at Emily.

She forced a smile on her face, “Brad, it’s YOUR birthday, so we do as you wish.”

“Good. Now let’s go back to your home. I have a class tomorrow at 8 am, so I don’t want to go to sleep too late…”

Abby chortled, “You can stay in OUR house… If I remember correctly, the bed in my room is large enough…”

“Abby dear, your offer is very tempting, but my clothes and all the stuff I have to take with me to class is in my house. We’ll talk about it some other time.

A disappointed look on Abby’s face was easy to spot, “OK, but if change your mind, you know where to find me…”

I kissed both women on their cheeks and left.

…

Until Saturday I went twice with Abby to the dog park and once I had dinner with both of them.

Abby was not supposed to start in our local college for another month, so she was mostly at home with Emily.

I arrived to their house at 7 pm.

Abby wore a short red dress displaying a generous cleavage.

I suspected that she wanted to remind me what I was missing by not giving in to her wishes to continue our intimate relationship…

Emily was having on a midi skirt with a nice blouse. She didn’t need to expose her cleavage, her ample boobs protruded nicely forward…

“Girls, now that I am an old man, let’s sip from this expensive French wine I bought especially for this evening. Cheers!”

I sat at the head of the table and the ladies on both my sides.

When we drank, I began telling them anecdotes of our college – About 2 ‘not-so-smart’ teachers, who got their job using connections, students who managed to hack an important test, a female teacher who got trapped in her car without being able to exit until the police showed up…

I tried the best I could to be interesting, yet kept an eye on their glasses, filling them to the rim whenever necessary.

An hour later both ladies were in a much more relaxed mood.

Emily smiled more and became more chatty.

Abby was laughing uncontrollably a lot, even when a silly story was mentioned.

By then Abby consumed 3 glasses of wine and Emily two. I had only one glass.

It was time to check my plan!

I knew that if I failed, it could be a disaster, but I didn’t know what else to do…

I moved behind Abby, placed both my palms on her shoulders and started massaging them.

She closed her eyes, leaned back on my tummy and moaned.

I said, “Abby, I love you and I always will. But since you left this house and moved to Boston, I spent a lot of time with your mother. And now I am in love with her too…”

Abby’s reaction showed that she misunderstood me, “Brad, that’s OK, we can be a happy family together.”

She put her hands on mine and tried to pull them down to her breasts.

“Abby, what do you mean by ‘a happy family’?”

“You will sleep with me in my room, and mom will become your stepmom…”

She pulled my hands more forcefully and I gave in.

I cupped both her boobs over her dress.

“Abby, you don’t get it. I love your mom as a woman! Not as a ‘mom’. And I think she is fond of me too…”

Abby opened her eyes and stared at her mom with confusion in her eyes, “Mom, you really love Brad?…”

Emily lowered her head and stayed mum.

Abby just glanced at her mom and wasn’t sure how to react.

My hands gently rubbed Abby’s tits and a moment later I inserted my right one inside her dress. I massaged her bare tit. The nipple was rock hard. She moaned again.

Emily just sat there mesmerized and watched Abby’s chest.

I whispered, “During your absence your mom and I became very close and even had sex together. I think that both of us love each other a lot! Abby, both I and Emily love you very much as well. There is a lot of love in this room… So we may form a family as you insinuated, but Emily’s role is not going to be ‘mother’. She will be just like you, a loving woman.”

At this point Abby was both tipsy and aroused by my manipulations of her breasts.

She was trying to clear her mind, “Brad, you want to have sex with me and… my mother in our house?… Mom, is this what you want too?!…”

Emily stayed silent.

My hand tweaked and then pinched her nipple.

Her head leaned back on my abdomen.

My prick began to throb. The hard organ behind her head did not escape Abby.