Not Quite the Brady Bunch Ch. 05

Kelly woke before the sun had even thought of coming up and edging through the shades that covered Emma’s bedroom window. She rolled onto her side and watched her eighteen-year-old little sister peacefully sleeping beside her. The night before was like a dream. First, seeing Emma masturbating and the two of them ending up naked together, making each cum, followed by the shock of listening to Emma and their stepfather, Mike, fucking. Adding to it, the fact that it excited her to a point where she fingered herself as she listened to them through the door then her fingered her little sister as Emma told her how Mike had fucked her in the ass and filled her with cum. It had to be a dream, right?

But she knew it wasn’t and the more she thought about it, the more aroused she became. For more than a year, she’d been exclusively with women, she wasn’t ready to say she was a lesbian yet but was leaning that way for sure. The jealousy and desire she felt as she imagined Mike slipping his cock into her baby sister, made her begin to question her leanings. She wanted it too. Wanted to taste him and feel the pleasure that she heard as Emma had screamed out the night before. She checked her phone, it was 4:30 in the morning.

Her hand reached out and ran softly over Emma’s bare shoulder. Fingers tracing a line up along the nape of her neck. Her flesh was warm and soft, and she stirred slightly, exhaling a soft moan. Kelly wasn’t the most experienced, she’d been with three men, well boys, and four women, but last night, Emma was a wild mess of passion, her lack of experience, coupled with her raw desire made for chaotic and loud sex. Leaning in towards Emma, she ran her lips along her collarbone, tasting her, and felt a warm tingle through her stomach. Emma rolled slightly to face her, eyes blinking as she woke, then smiling sweetly as she focused on her sister.

“Morning Kel,” she whispered softly.

Kelly kissed her gently and ran her fingers softly along her cheek. Propping herself up on her elbow she looked at her sister and said quietly, “Did you sleep well?”

Emma moaned softly and stretched with a nod, then reached out and wrapped her arms around Kelly. The two sisters were very similarly built and would have been easily mistaken for twins except that Kelly was a couple inches shorter and wore her hair much shorter, not even to her shoulders and had streaks of bleached white that softened the color. She had developed a very strong lower body over years of highly competitive soccer, which resulted in a thicker and more pronounced, though perfectly shaped, butt. Emma, on the other hand, was thin and wiry with long hair that was their natural chestnut brown. Both had small breasts, topped with cone shaped dark pink nipples that became very pronounced when the girls got sexually excited.

“Emma,” Kelly said softly, “I want to ask you something.”

Emma thought she knew what Kelly was about to say, but just nodded and waited to hear what was on her mind.

“I was wondering if you would let me join you and Mike?” she whispered. As the words came out, she realized she had probably just crossed the line. She wasn’t always sure where Emma’s lines were, and in this situation, it could be anywhere. She wished she could take it back, but it was too late, it was out there. “Fuck,” she thought.

Emma looked at her blankly, unsure how to react. That was not at all what she was expecting. After the way Kelly had responded to her telling her about her anal experience, she was expecting Kelly to want her to play with her ass or something. She never even considered the idea that she might be interested in Mike, much less joining them in bed.

“You mean the three of us together?” she stammered.

Kelly just nodded, trying to think of a way to undo what she had just done. The joy and excitement of the last day and night was probably going to turn into a shit show in about two seconds.

Emma felt a twinge of jealousy. Mike was hers. She had waited so long for this and now Kelly wanted to take him from her. She started to get angry, but as she looked in Kelly’s eyes the anger subsided and her lust for new sexual experiences started to enter into the equation. “OK,” she said, the words struggling to get out of her throat. It didn’t sound very convincing. She paused for a moment, then added, “but I need you to promise me something.”

Kelly nodded.

“Only when it’s the three of us, not just the two of you alone, OK?” she said with a bit of unease in her voice.

Kelly could tell she wasn’t entirely sure she wanted this, but she hadn’t blown up, so she could walk this back. “Emma, if you’re not absolutely sure you want this, we don’t have to do it. I feel bad for even asking you to be honest, it just kind of slipped out,” she responded as she stroked Emma’s cheek softly.

Emma was pensive as she thought, then softly said, “But you were thinking about it, a lot, that’s why you asked, right.”

“Yeah, I guess,” Kelly responded.

Emma sat for a second, thinking, imagining the three of them together, and that’s what did it, made her sure. “No, I want it, for sure, Kel,” she said confidently, “but I still want you to promise, only when it’s the three of us, OK?”

Kelly smiled, “I promise, only when it’s all three of us, never just me and Mike,” she said.

“Thank you, Kel,” Emma said softly.

Emma kissed her and slid out from under the covers, taking her hand and leading her down the hall. The two naked girls slipped quietly through the bedroom door and up to the edge of the king-sized bed. Emma let go of Kelly’s hand and crawled up on to the bed, lifting the blanket and sheet in the dark. He stirred a bit, and she froze, stifling a giggle. As he settled, her hand moved to his soft cock, he was still naked, and grasped it lightly as Kelly carefully crawled up beside her.

Kelly’s hand joined Emma’s and they began to stroke Mike’s cock, feeling it stiffen. Mike moaned and his eyes opened slowly, the dark room. The girls continued to stroke his cock, a little faster as it stiffened, and he moaned and pressed his head back into the pillow. He felt the warmth of soft lips sliding over the head and down his shaft and his hips pressed up reflexively. He reminded himself to be quiet, Kelly was down the hall and might be up soon.

As Emma slid her mouth over his cock, Kelly’s hand moved to his balls, cupping them and squeezing them gently as she leaned down and whispered in his ear, “She does amazing things with her tongue doesn’t she, Daddy.”

Mikes head and shoulders shot up, hearing Kelly’s voice in his ear.” What the…Kelly?” he stammered.

Kelly giggled and pushed him back down, moving her mouth to his and kissing him. Her tongue pressing between his lips and swirling with his as he moaned. Emma’s mouth moved slowly up and down his cock, her tongue wrapping around it. The shy and hesitant girl of two days ago, replaced with a confident young woman using her body to please him. Mike was still trying to deal with the Kelly situation in his head, as her tongue was swirling around with his.

Kelly pulled her lips from his and squeezed his balls a little tighter as she whispered seductively, “My turn.” Mike felt Emma’s mouth slide off his cock, quickly replaced by Kelly’s. Kelly’s technique was very different, her lips grasped his cock, and she sucked as she moved slowly up and down his cock. Mikes eyes began to adjust to the darkness, and he could make out the two young women’s forms, shadows in the darkness, Kelly’s head bobbing up and down between his legs as Emma placed her hands on his chest and lay her chin on them.

“She enjoyed listening to us last night so much that she wanted a taste of you for herself,” she said as she looked at his eyes in the darkness. She lay there watching him, barely able to make out his features in the darkness, feeling his chest rise and fall under her, feeling his hips press up as Kelly latched onto the base of his cock and pulled slowly up with her lips.

When she reached the head, Kelly released her grip and his cock popped from her mouth. Her hand grasped his shaft and gently stroked it as Mike saw her rise up and straddle his hips, then felt her pussy surround his cock and she sank down on him. He let out a long deep moan and Emma moved up and kissed him softly before she rose up on her knees, turned around and straddled his face. She leaned forward and kissed Kelly as she lowered herself onto his lips, his tongue popping out to dance over her clit and explore her deliciously sweet pussy.

The two girls kissed passionately as they fucked him, moaning and squealing with delight. Mikes hands moved up and grasped Kelly’s hips as his hips drove up to meet her thrusts. Kelly moved up and down while she thrust her hips forward, finding the perfect angle and driving herself to orgasm. Her pussy was now a sloppy, wet mess and she continued to ride his cock, loving the feel of the wetness between her legs. His breathing became harder and shorter, and he struggled to breathe a little as Emma rode his face. His moans became grunts and his fingers dug into Kelly’s hips as he prepared to cum.

Kelly sensed it and moved quickly off his cock, she wasn’t on birth control, because she rarely fucked men. She slid down quickly and wrapped her lips around his cock. Her pussy, mixed with remnants of Emma from last night was like nothing she’d ever tasted. She sucked hard and her mouth urged the cum from his cock. His hips thrashed as he unloaded into her mouth. She struggled a bit at first but swallowed enough to not have to pull off. Mike was grunting and gasping while Emma kept grinding hard on his tongue. Once she had finished milking his cock, Kelly slid back up and pressed her lips against Emma’s, she slid her tongue into Emma’s mouth, passing a good bit of cum to her sister. She held Emma tight as she began to squirm, groping at one of her swollen nipples. Emma gasped and squealed as she began to cum, her dampness turning into a gush of pleasure and coating Mike’s face.