“Okay… fine.” I took a sip of my beer. “Who goes first?”
“Well, since you are outnumbered, you may go.”
Immediately put on the spot, I had no idea what I would even want to ask of any of them. So, I simply got the ball rolling, “Okay, Kelly, Truth or Dare.”
“Truth!” She said emphatically.
“Okay… ummm… have you ever smoked a joint?”
It was stupid. A silly wasted question, but I honestly didn’t known where the lines were. There were always unspoken rules with Truth or Dare depending on your company. Things you could, and could not ask of the participants.
Kelly just giggled, “Yes, I have.”
“Really?” I was genuinely surprised, “When?”
All three girls burst out laughing and Nadine kicked in, “This afternoon behind the garage!!”
The water practically shook with laughter, and that was even with the jets going.
“Are you serious??”
Kelly nodded her head giggling, with tears in her eyes. I was astonished. It would seem my aunts weren’t at all as subdued as I had been led to believe, and if anything were now drunk and probably still a little high.
“My turn!” Nadine cried out, “Jack, Truth or Dare.”
Figuring she’d ask about my love life again and not really minding to answer, I said, “Truth.”
She grinned at me with that same mischievous look, “Have you ever jerked off to any of us?”
Wham. She got me out of the blue with that question and I immediately felt like a 13-year-old who was suddenly in very big trouble. I was drinking my beer at the time and literally spit it out, coughing. If my face weren’t already blazing red, choking on my suds didn’t help.
“Nadine!” Kelly and Tammy again chided her, aghast.
“Oh, c’mon! We’re in the game now. He’s gotta answer.”
They all turned to face me expectantly, as if bound by the rules that the immortals of Truth or Dare wrote down before time started.
“Holy cow.” I said, dropping my face in my hands. I couldn’t possibly look them in the eyes when I affirmed it.
“C’mon! Answer” Nadine called.
Forehead cradled in my hand, avoiding their eyes, I slowly nodded.
“Who??” Nadine fired back.
“Hang on!” I looked up and shouted like I was on trial, “That’s two questions!”
“You asked two about Kelly smoking a joint. C’mon, fair’s fair. Plus, I think we make it ‘one truth and one follow-up question to the truth.’ Can I get a second?”
Unbelievably, Kelly and Tammy’s hands both shot up and they said in unison, “I!”
Nadine, now the judge, jury and executioner of this little game declared the motion carried and they all cast their expectant looks back at me.
“C’mon, Jacky Boy…” she cooed, “Which one of us..?”
“Uhhh….” I stalled, but knew there was no delaying the inevitable. “It’s not just one.”
Kelly and Tammy gasped, but Nadine just grinned like the Cheshire Cat. “Jaaaaaaaack,” she teased, “You told us it’s more than one. You didn’t say who. The question, young Jack, was ‘which of your fave’wit aunties have you cum to?'” She giggled obscenely at how red she could make my face go.
“Nadine! He’s going to have a heart attack! Look at his face!” Tammy tried to stop her but she was rampaging right over the top of me.
I took a deep breath, and simply got it over with, “All of you.”
I think this revelation surprised Kelly and Tammy most of all. “Awwwwww!” They cooed at me, both of them had a dreamy look in their eyes as if I’d just made each of their day. Nadine still held the mischief in her eyes but she seemed more at peace now that the secret was out.
“Okay! Who’s turn is it now?” I questioned, trying desperately to change the subject.
“I’ll go!” Tammy said, “Nadine, Truth or Dare.”
“Dare.” She said it quickly, with finality. As if no answer could possibly be simpler. There were always those T&D players that went for Dare every time.
“Okaaaay…” Tammy said, “Well, since you’ve been so horrible to poor Jack… Show him your tits.”
My eyes went wide and my breath caught in my throat. Tammy looked at me and gave me a wink and a smile, as if she knew she’d just done me a huge favor. Nadine however, turned to look at me and the vixen was back.
“I’ll go one better,” she said.
By now, I’m hard as a rock and thankful that there was cloudy bubbles of water all around us. Nadine stood up, into the center of the hot tub and then climbed up on my side, put her knees on either side of where I was sitting, and held herself on her knees above my crotch. Her bikini top, struggling to hold her tits, was inches from my face.
I couldn’t hear anything but the beating of my own heart as a I looked at them more closely than I ever had before. I inspected every sunkissed freckle. Every wrinkle and stretch mark from the swelling of three kids breastfeeding. I could still smell the suntan lotion she rubbed into them earlier that day and I saw the beads of sweat from the heat of the hot tub coating each delicious orb.
I saw her hands start at her upper chest and rub down over each breast slowly, before pulling the bikini down, revealing her dark brown milk saucer areolas. She hooked her bikini under each tit and it gave them a boost, holding them higher up and closer together.
Aunt Nadine was for the first time, bare breasted in front of me, and my heart was pounding when one of her fingers tilted my chin so I was looking her in the face. She smiled down at me and moved her hands up to either side of my face, running her fingers through my hair lovingly until she reached the back of my head, gripped my hair roughly, thrust out her chest and I felt her warm, sweaty tits envelope my face as she pulled my face roughly into her fleshy chest.
She worked my head this way and that, up and down, round and round. They were so big, and soft. Like nothing I’d ever felt before, but everything I’d imagined and more. I felt the nubs of her nipples in the center of her large areolas perk up and travel around my face. I opened my mouth and even managed to suck one in, feeling it harden further, and tasting the saltiness of her skin.
Her hands paused from moving me around and allowed me to tease her nipple with my tongue, and I was in heaven.
When she let go, I sucked in a breath and she kissed me on the forehead before returning to her seat in silence, a very self-satisfied look on her face. Kelly was staring wide-eyed at me, almost in a daze. Tammy’s mouth hung open in shock looking at Nadine who was leaning back, tits still out on full display, no intention of putting them back under covers.
“Who’s turn is it?” She asked rhetorically. “Kelly, I believe.”
No response from Kelly. Nadine splashed her in the face. “Kelly! Earth to Kelly!” My eyes were still on Nadine’s exposed boobs and watched them jiggle as she did so.
Kelly snapped out of it, wiped her face, and started giggling, which set them all off giggling, which set me off too. Tension officially eased, we got back to the game.
“Um, okay. So… Jack asked me. Nadine asked Jack. Tammy asked Nadine. So, I’ll ask Tammy. Tammy, Truth or Dare?”
Tammy giggled, “I think I’ll start with a Dare. Knowing you, I think I’ll get a pretty tame one.”
Kelly was offended. “What’s that supposed to mean??” She slurred.
“Oh, c’mon Kel. You know you’re a bit of a prude.” Nadine remarked. Not unkindly. Just matter-of-factly. It was a relatively easy accusation for her to make, since she had her tits on full display.
Kelly scoffed, crossed her arms, and pouted. “No, I’m not!”
“Oh, yeah?” Nadine challenged. “Prove it. Take your swimsuit off. I DARE you.”
Kelly’s jaw dropped in shock. I don’t think anyone in the tub was truly wondering whether or not she’d do it.
“Fine!” she cried. “I’ll do it! But you can’t call me a prude again!”
“IF you do it, Kel, and IF you go sit on your nephew’s crotch and grind into what felt like a pretty stiff cock to me,” she said giving me a side look and a wink, “then I won’t call you a prude, again.”
At this point, everyone but Nadine was in shock. I was absolutely in love with the idea. Just because Kelly wasn’t exactly my preferred body type, having her grinding on me while naked was an amazing prospect, and definitely one I’d cum to in my teens.
“Fine!” Kelly said, stumbling to her feet in the pool, starting to pull the strap of her swimsuit off her shoulder. “Fine, I will!”
My eyes were darting from Kelly, to Tammy who was darting her eyes around as well, to Nadine who was sitting calmly with her tits out.
“Nadine! Stop it! Tell Kelly to stop!” Meanwhile, Kelly was struggling to get out of her suit, but in her drunkenness was finding it difficult.
Nadine rolled her eyes. “Kelly, stop! You can’t do that.”
Kelly had managed to get one of her boobs out, and this is where my eyes were. It was quite lovely. I found I’d misjudged her. Teardrop shaped. No where near as big as Nadine’s, but that was no secret. They would have been a very small handful. It had a delicious looking nipple, hardened in the cool night air, protruding from the end of it.
She glared down at Nadine, “Why not?” She said, angrily.
“Because it wasn’t my turn. It’s yours. So, sit down, pull your top up…” Kelly immediately blushed, looked at me, saw where I was looking, and then sheepishly smiled as she pulled her shoulder strap back over her breast, to my disappointment.
“…and dare Tammy to do something. She chose Dare.”
Kelly splashed back into the water and resettled herself.
So, in the brief time we’d been playing Truth or Dare, I’d admitted that I’d cum to all of them in the past… I’d seen one of Kelly’s breasts… and had my whole face rubbed in Nadine’s amazing tits. If it stopped there, I would have been very happy.
“C’mon, Kelly. I’m ready. Dare me.” Tammy said, trying to keep the train going away from Kelly grinding on my lap naked. Meanwhile, it had occurred to none of them to ask if I even wanted that, but I suppose they didn’t really need to, did they?
“While you think, I’m going for another bottle of wine.” Nadine stood up, proudly with her tits on display, shook them like a stripper in my direction, and stepped out of the tub. “This better be good, Kelly!” she called behind her.
Kelly glared after Nadine. “Okay, Tammy… I dare you… to… I dare you to… ummm…” She was struggling. I don’t think she could possibly take more wine. I didn’t even know if she could get out a coherent dare.
Leave a Reply