Tara answered “Nothing happened”, while at the same time Dave, with a huge grin on his face, was making hand job motions.
I suspected more than that may have happened but figured I’d get the details later. We talked awkwardly for a while and came to the agreement that today never happened. Tara’s boyfriend never needed to know. Jamie never needed to know. As long as you keep our secret, we’ll keep yours. Then we all went back to swimming and playing and having fun as if nothing had ever happened. The only difference being there was a lot more touching going on. I caught Tara eyeballing my pants a couple times, and Dave eyeballing Melissa more than a couple of times.
Eventually Dave and I left and he gave me all the details. Tara had given him a blow job right there in the back yard. When he tried to get her bikini off to return the favor she wouldn’t let him. He tried to get her horny enough to just go for it by using his fingers but just couldn’t get her there.
I told him “You should have got some weed and loosened her up”
He asked “Is that what you did?”
I said “No, that’s what SHE did, I was so stoned the only thing I remember is that it was fucking incredible”
Dave answered “I know, I saw”
He told me that when he and Tara came back over looking for us and we weren’t there, she figured she would check inside. She popped her head in the door right when I was pounding Melissa doggy style. Dave said she came back with her eyes the size of dinner plates and said “They’re doing it!” Dave of course had to see for himself and so popped his head in the door too. He was just in time to see Melissa on top of me riding with her head thrown back and making a lot of noise. After that he just grinned at me.
I know that Dave and Tara did see each other again after that day. He gave me details of a couple visits. Apparently the girl was really wild. Any time her boyfriend was away for whatever sport he was doing, she would meet Dave and they would just fuck like rabbits. That info would come in handy later.
Blackmail
The next time I saw Melissa was the week after Jamie finally came home. I was terrified that Melissa was going to absent mindedly say something and spill the whole thing but luckily she didn’t. Later in the day though she did come over and sit with me for a while to talk.
She told me all she’d been thinking about all afternoon was me fucking Jamie. Did I fuck her since she’s been back? (Yes I did) How many times? Was it as good as with her? What position? OMG I bet Jamie likes it doggie style. (She does) Finally I had to tell her to shut up already.
Melissa said “I can’t help it. Just the thought of you fucking her makes me so fucking horny. And remembering you fucking ME makes me even hornier. I wanna do it again. C’mon right now, let’s go find a place and do it!”
I thought about that for a minute. She was absolutely beautiful, and so sexy in the little outfit she was wearing at the time. Then I saw Jamie smiling at me from across the deck and I just had to say no. I was seriously in love with this girl and didn’t want to risk that by fucking her best friend, AGAIN.
Melissa pulled her chair up real close to me and whispered into my ear…
“If you DON’T come and fuck me, whenever I want you to, then I’ll tell Jamie that you DID” and she just smiled at me.
My mouth dropped. I said “she won’t believe you, she knows I wouldn’t do that.. she knows YOU wouldn’t do that!”
She answered “But you did, didn’t you. Besides, we’ve been best friend since second grade, who do you think she’ll believe, you or me?”
I sat there shaking my head from side to side saying “You evil bitch. You’re gonna tell her that you fucked her boyfriend while she was away at camp? You would do that to your best friend?”
She said “No, I’m going to tell her that you got me high and you took advantage of me while I wasn’t thinking straight. She’ll definitely believe that. She’s seen me high before” again with the evil smile.
Son of a bitch.
Then she added “So every once in a while we’re gonna do it again. How can that be bad?”
I answered “You know if Jamie ever finds out she’ll dump me and never speak to either of us again”
She smiled and said “Well you just be a good bad boy and do what you’re told, and she’ll never have to find out”
I couldn’t believe it. I was so caught by surprise that I couldn’t think of a way out of this. In order for her to not tell my girlfriend that I cheated on her, I had to continue cheating on her. I also couldn’t believe that I was upset at the prospect of “having to” fuck Melissa, any guy I know would beg for the chance. I just couldn’t think of any way out. Would Jamie believe me if I denied it? Or if I told her that I was so high I didn’t even remember doing it? Did I want to risk her finding out at all?
I had no choice. I was now Melissa’s personal sex toy. Any time she called, I had to show up. In order to keep the girl I was madly in love with, I had to continue fucking her best friend.
Leave a Reply