Sara frowned, saying, “Look, you two have already opened up your relationship to trying new things, so how is that sneaking behind his back? You’d just be doing something you’ve always wanted to do while your husband plays pool.”
Ellen hesitantly looked at Michael and Wayne playing pool, then said, “I’m sorry, Sara. I just can’t! I’m not like you. I can’t be unfaithful to Michael like that, even with how our relationship is now.”
They’d known each other since they were both little girls in elementary school. Sara knew Ellen better than almost everyone else and she understood Ellen’s decision to not go out and fuck Wayne in his car, even if she was a little disappointed that Ellen wasn’t willing to do it. She and Michael had always been very open and honest with each other, and neither ever lied or kept secrets from the other.
Sara nodded her understanding to Ellen, but after a couple of minutes added, “Then at least see if Michael will let you take Wayne back to your room. Remind him it’s been one of you fantasies.”
Ellen swallowed hard and struggled to find her words, and Sara said, “You’ll never know what he’ll say unless you ask him. If he says no at least you tried, and if he agrees you get to live out another fantasy for real.”
Feeling her heart racing at the idea, Ellen caught herself and replied, “I just couldn’t do that to Michael. This isn’t like before.”
Sensing Ellen’s unspoken desires, Sara wasn’t willing to let things go yet. She looked Ellen straight in the eyes and asked, “Why not? Michael loves you enough that he let you live out your biggest fantasy. And wasn’t having sex with a stranger also one of your fantasies? What if you could have sex with a total stranger, with Michael there as emotional support? Or even better fuck both a stranger AND Michael? Would you do that if you could?”
Ellen glanced once more at both Michael and Wayne, and realized she was actually thinking about Sara’s wild ideas! Her heartbeat pounding in her chest, she turned back to Sara and timidly said, “I don’t know… maybe… but ONLY if Michael was okay with it.”
Then she added, “Just because Michael was understanding once doesn’t mean it should be a habit to keep asking him to be. That’s unfair to him!”
Sara grinned widely and sitting back said, “Just ask him! The worst he can say is no, and you’re not out anything if he does because you were honest and up front with him. After what we all did together at the sex club I’m betting he’d be open to that idea. Michael’s sooo cool that way!”
Ellen unconsciously gazed over at both men once more, lost in the thoughts swirling around in her head, and quietly responded “Okay, maybe. But I don’t know what to say though.”
As Ellen finished saying that, the three guys came back to the table and sat down. Michael leaned over and kissed Ellen on her head, and the guys all started chatting again about their game.
A few minutes later Sara gave Ellen a wickedly mischievous look and hopped up. Leaning Michael closer towards Ellen, she whispered just loudly enough that only the three of them could hear, “Ellen has something to ask you.”
Then smiling mischievously Sara asked Wayne and Jerry to excuse the three of them for just a couple of minutes, and at Sara’s not-so-subtle urging both Michael and Ellen got up and she led them out front.
Once they were outside, Sara took Ellen’s trembling hand and turned to Michael, and in the staggeringly blunt way she’s so notorious for, blurted out, “Ellen wants to fuck Wayne. Do you think you’d be okay with that?”
Shocked and mortified by Sara’s tactless outburst, Ellen gasped and stammered, “Sara! I never said that! Not really.”
But Sara just laughed and said, “Yes you did, sort of. I asked you if you’d ever fuck Wayne if you had a chance, and you said you would, but only IF Michael was okay with it.”
Then whirling back around and looking Michael in the eyes, Sara crossed her arms and asked, “Well? WOULD you be okay with that? With Ellen fucking Wayne? With Ellen fulfilling her fantasy of having sex with a stranger?”
Caught completely off guard, Michael was speechless for a long moment. Before he could respond Sara quickly added, “What if Ellen wanted to fuck BOTH of you? Would you be okay with that?”
Michael looked at his wife, and saw that while she was stunned and embarrassed by Sara’s bluntness and questions she was also nibbling on her bottom lip nervously. Michael knew Ellen so well and so completely that he understood just what that subconscious tell meant for her, even if she never actually said anything out loud.
Getting a better grasp on what might be going on here, Michael said, “Maybe, yeah, if that’s what Ellen REALLY wants and you’re not just teasing her into doing something!”
Smiling hugely now, Sara turned to Ellen and asked, “Would you be willing to fuck a complete stranger if Michael was there with you being supportive? Would you live out that fantasy if you could? I know you! I know you’ve been thinking about it now!”
Ellen’ blushed brightly and felt her face get so hot, then nibbling her bottom lip and unable to raise her face to meet Sara’s eyes Ellen softly stammered, “Yes…”
Sara asked, “What about fucking BOTH Michael and a complete stranger? Would you ever do that? I’ll bet you’d think that was sooo hot. The excitement of your husband sharing you with someone completely unknown, having sex together all at the same time!”
Ellen looked at Michael uncertainly, her face a storm of pleading and worry, and he saw she wanted to do this but she was very concerned about what he might think. What he might think of her!
With Sara’s statements making the final piece of this puzzle fall in place in his head, Michael looked at Ellen standing there so nervously, and said, “Our relationship has changed so much now, and for the better I think. I understand sooo many things about how you think and feel even better than I ever did before.”
The he gave her a reassuring wink and added, “Sweetheart, if you really want this, and if everyone is okay with it, then of course you can do this. You DON’T need my permission, I don’t control you, and I’ll never do that to you.”
Her heart skipped a beat as excitement flooded in and Ellen ran to him, wrapping her arms tightly around her wonderful husband. Michael leaned over and kissed Ellen’s forehead and continued, “I can see how much you want this, my beautiful angel, and I’m okay with it because YOU want this.”
He grinned at her, and to lighten the moment he said, “Not like I haven’t seen you with another man or two before anyway.”
Ellen’s jaw dropped in shocked surprise at that and she replied, “Oh you! You are sooo naughty!” In mock indignation she socked Michael in the chest with her small fist.
Sara laughed and smiled broadly. She leaned up and gave Michael a quick appreciative kiss, and taking her two dearest friends by their hands she led the way back to their table.
Once they were all sitting down again Sara started flirting outrageously with Jerry for several minutes, and then seductively turned and asked Wayne, “Isn’t Ellen gorgeous tonight? We went to our friend’s wedding earlier today, and I helped Ellen do her hair and makeup. She’s just gorgeous, isn’t she? ”
Wayne gave a quick, nervous glance at Michael for her putting him on the spot, then diplomatically replied, “Yeah, she’s very pretty.”
Sara crossed her arms in an over-dramatized pouty sulk, and looking at Wayne said “NO! Not just pretty, she’s GORGEOUS!”
Wayne, suddenly feeling stuck in an awkward situation, nodded and replied, “Yeah, you’re right. She is gorgeous.”
Then Sara leaned over and not very quietly whispered in Jerry’s ear, “Do you think Ellen is gorgeous enough that Wayne would ever want to fuck her?”
Jerry looked surprised for a moment, but laughed, “Oh, I know he would!” Wayne looked shocked and cast a panicked look at the large and imposing Michael. Both Michael and Sara noticed Ellen fought back a faint, flattered smile at Jerry’s response.
Michael turned to look at Ellen, and she almost imperceptibly looked at him imploringly. Michael turned back to look at Wayne, and grinning at him winked and said, “Only a fool wouldn’t want to fuck her. She’s hot AND damn good in bed”.
Jerry gave him a quick elbow nudge as Wayne stifled his shock at Michael’s words, then managed to regain his composure and responded, “I’ll bet she is!” Wayne looked at Ellen and added, “And I’ve never been accused of being a fool!”
Ellen blushed nervously, and squeezed her hands tightly together under the table, but with a hint of excitement too she smiled demurely at him.
Seeing Ellen’s response, Sara stood up and said, “Well, I’ve decided Jerry is going to get lucky tonight, so I’m going to take him back to my room now and fuck his brains out.”
Then with an impish look at Ellen, Michael, and Wayne she added, “And you three really should go back to Ellen’s room.”
Sara looked Ellen in the eyes and asked, “So gorgeous, what do YOU think about that?”
Ellen shyly looked at Wayne and said, “We could do that I guess, if Wayne wanted to.”
Wayne looked at Michael, who nodded his head towards Ellen and said, “You heard her,” and winked again.
Sara took Ellen’s trembling hand and walked her to over between Michael and Wayne, and put her hand into Wayne’s. Then she turned and looking at Jerry said, “Come on baby, time to get lucky,” and headed for the door. With a grin Jerry followed her, hypnotized by the sway of her tight ass as she walked away.
Michael stood up next, turned and kissed Ellen, and said, “Well, C’mon you two,” then proceeded to follow Sara out too.
Ellen bashfully looked up at Wayne, and still holding her hand he also got up and they followed everyone out the door too. Once outside, Sara and Jerry said their goodbyes and headed off in his car to her room.
Wayne had to let go of Ellen’s hand to retrieve his car, but said he’d follow her and Michael to their hotel. Michael and Ellen climbed into his truck and they led way.
On the way Michael double-checked that Ellen was really okay with this, asking, “Are you sure you really want this to happen, sweetheart? Do you really want to to have sex with Wayne? Or is this something Sara’s teased you into committing to? Yes or no, I’m okay with whatever you decide.”
Leave a Reply