“So, what has Alyssa never done for you, I’ll let that wish come true”
Alyssa… What was Jonah going to tell her? Her heart would be broken by what he was doing. He then thought about the things she said to him earlier.
‘I just wanted to tell you that this is just sex between us’
‘It’s not some kind of romantic thing going on. Don’t get it confused’
‘Don’t come crawling to me because you need a fix’
Although those words and logic told him that nothing was wrong. His heart was telling him differently. The truth was, he did have feelings and they recently have been locked away. He kept telling himself that she didn’t want anything to do with him romantically. There was still some residue of his feelings for her that currently existed, but day by day, he was healing.
With all these thoughts, Jonah just looked to the floor and had a distraught look on his face. Angela saw it and knew she did wrong mentioning Alyssa’s name.
‘Shit, I hit a touchy subject’
She got a hold of his face and apologized,
“Hey, Jonah, I’m sorry, I won’t bring up her name anymore, okay?”
Jonah looked at her face and could see sincerity. He really appreciated that, he smiled at her responding,
“Thank You”
She then gently caressed his right cheek and gave him a reassuring smile saying,
“You’re welcome, I just wanted to give you something that you’ve always wanted to try. Anything”
Jonah was quite perplexed by her kindness. One day, she was blackmailing him, the next, she was offering any form of sexual gratification. He then saw Angela lean over her desk and put her right hand on it. She took a deep breath and spread her left butt cheek with her left hand asking,
“Have you ever tried this hole before?”
Jonah was stunned by such an offer. He could see how pink her anus was. It was very small and frail looking. Like a precious little flower. Was she really offering her anus for his pleasure? Sodomy? He didn’t know how to answer her question. He just answered honestly.
“No”
“Would you like to try it?”
“I… uh…”
Angela giggled,
“I’ll take that as a yes”
Angela opened her desk and pulled out some lube. She put some on her left hand and tossed it to Jonah.
“Put some on your cock and just wait for me to stretch it out first. There’s no way I can take that monster right from the get go”
Jonah always believed that sodomy was sinful. He wanted to refuse Angela, but the sight of her asshole aroused him for some reason. It was just so tiny and cute with its wrinkly pink texture. The only word that came out of his mouth was,
“Okay”
He applied the lube to his cock and made sure to cover everything. He was starting to stoke himself from the sight of Angela shoving three lubed pens up her ass. She then used a forth and then a fifth. He already felt like cumming and it didn’t help that she was moaning while doing it too.
Angela was excited, but nervous at the same time. She was always curious, but never got the chance. She’d only taken her fingers and small objects in there. She moaned on purpose to give Jonah a good show. She looked back and saw that he was already stroking himself. She smiled at her success. She then got a sixth pen and shoved it in. She was enjoying it just as much as Jonah was watching, if not more so.
“Okay, let’s try it”
Angela laid on her back on top of her desk and put her knees to her chest. She still had the pens in her ass, so she pushed them out and they all fell to the floor. Jonah got into position and began to press. He could see a look of worry in her eyes. He asked in concern,
“What’s wrong?”
“Nothing, I’m fine”
“You look worried, I just don’t want to see you uncomfortable”
“What? You’re… concerned? For me?”
“Well… yeah, I mean I care about everyone”
No matter how much wrong someone has done Jonah, he never held a grudge. It was a Christian upbringing. Love thy neighbor as thyself. Love thy enemy. Forgive those who have afflicted you. The concepts of love and forgiveness. One he felt many Christian of today didn’t follow.
Angela was quite touched by his caring nature. She really liked and appreciated it. She decided to be honest with him. She didn’t take him for the asshole type who would laugh at her.
“I’ve… never done it back there before”
“Oh, did, did you wanna stop then? We don’t have to do this”
“NO!!! Please, I wanna try it. Please”
She gave Jonah begging puppy dog eyes,
“Pweety Pwease”
Jonah could not resist. She was turning him on. There was something about the woman being submissive that he enjoyed. Angela couldn’t help it either. She WAS a submissive. She was blackmailing this man and now she’s begging him for his cock instead of commanding him. She found it so funny. She said that she wanted Jonah to be her toy, but deep down inside, she wanted to be Jonah’s toy. However, she was not ready to share that with him quite yet. She’d let him know later, but not today.
Jonah found Angela’s sudden change of demeanor to be quite attractive. She could tell that he enjoyed her coyness. Perhaps he may one day just come visit her and have sex with her without her requesting it. She smiled at the thought.
“Okay, but please let me know if you wanna stop” Jonah said, snapping her out of her thoughts.
“I will”
Jonah began to press into Angela’s sphincter. She relaxed and the head started to enter. She gasped at the sensation and she caressed his face, giving him a smile. Jonah stopped penetrating her. He was worried, but then her smile calmed him. He started to press in again. So many thoughts were going through Angela’s head,
‘I’m actually doing it! I’m getting fucked in the ass!’
‘I’m glad he’s not trying to fuck me right away’
‘He’s so caring and sweet’
Jonah held her hand as a means of comfort to show that he would halt his sexual desires if she were uncomfortable. Angela really liked that, especially because she was a bit nervous right now. Despite the blackmail from Angela, Jonah found her sudden timid look to be quite cute. It wasn’t exactly something Alyssa was good at.
“Mmm, Jonah, you’re putting it in such a dirty place. It turns me on so much”
Jonah pressed in more, encouraged from what Angela said. Angela moaned as they continued to hold hands. Jonah looked into her eyes and she looked back. Jonah got this strange feeling that it wasn’t just lust in her eyes. Like it was some form of affection. He then looked down and saw that his cock was completely buried in Angela’s ass. Before he could start moving, Angela said as she smiled at him,
“Leave it like this for a bit, it feels so nice”
“O…kay…”
Angela closed her eyes and rubbed Jonah’s hand sensually. She then used her other hand to rub her clitoris. Her pussy was already leaking down onto her ass and Jonah’s pubic area. The feeling was wonderful. She knew it was going to be good, but she didn’t think it would be this good. The thought of Jonah’s cock being so invasive to her most forbidden virgin hole was what got her off the most. After having Jonah wait and watch her touch herself, Angela felt that her asshole had enough time to get accustomed to the stretch. Angela opened her eyes to look back at Jonah.
“Alright baby, you can start moving”
Jonah moved his hips backwards, making his cock pull out slowly. It was like nothing he’d ever experienced before. Angela’s tight ring clung to him as if it didn’t want him to go. It was snug around the base of his cock. In contrast, the inside was warm and soft. He loved it. Jonah could do nothing but moan to her,
“Angela!… it feels… so good!”
“Same here!”
Angela was enjoying this just as much as Jonah. She always felt so dirty and kinky when she shoved her fingers or pens back there, but this was a whole other level of anal pleasure. She felt her asshole stretch and her rectum filling. It turned her on so much to know that Jonah was 9 inches deep inside her dirty back door. She stroked her clitoris faster as she released all tension back there.
“Yes! That’s it! Yes! Fuck me! Fuck my tight ass!”
Jonah only responded by moving faster. Despite his opinion on how sinful anal sex was, he was really enjoying it deep down. It turned him on that he was committing an act so taboo. He grabbed Angela’s breasts and caressed them. He switched between giving her breasts a squeeze and giving her nipples a rub.
Angela stopped rubbing her clitoris and used her fingers instead to insert into her pussy. She kept her other hand with Jonah’s. Her pointer and middle slipped in with ease. She thrusted her fingers in and out, trying to match Jonah’s rhythm with her ass. This beat a hairbrush and pen any day.
With the new sensations that both were experiencing, it wasn’t long before,
“Jonah, I’m gonna cum!!!”
“Me too!!!”
“Cum with me! Cum inside my ass baby! I want you to fill it up ‘til I can shit nothing but cum for a week!”
That last sentence, oddly enough, did not turn Jonah off, but rather on.
“ANGELA, I’M CUMMING!!!”
Jonah began to shoot load upon load into Angela. She was cumming with Jonah. Her vaginal muscles hugged her fingers as she had her strong orgasm. She could feel Jonah squirting a lot of cum inside her. It was so dirty to her and she loved it. There was no way it wouldn’t leak out once he pulled it out. Jonah had experienced his cum leaking out every now and then with Alyssa, but the anus was a much tighter hole. It gave a different feel.
He pulled out and immediately, some spilled out onto the floor. Angela could feel some of it running down the crack of her ass, so she tightened her butt cheeks and her sphincter. She wanted to keep his cum inside her. She always fantasized about having cum inside her ass for a whole day.
“Jonah… That was incredible!!!”
“Are you okay? It doesn’t hurt or anything does it?”
“I’m fine, don’t worry”
Angela appreciated Jonah’s continued concern post anal. She really liked that in a man. She had had too many asshole boyfriends and fuck buddies who were inconsiderate narcissistic bastards. She once had a guy who actually made her vomit because he was too rough with her mouth during oral and he had the nerve to blame her.
“Okay, I’m just making sure, wouldn’t want you in pain or even discomfort”
Leave a Reply